1. The Proposal
Updated: Oct 13
The applicant, P R & S A Boyles, plans to knock down four free-range broiler sheds and build four much larger indoor sheds. The birds would spend their whole lives indoors. The number of birds on site at any one time would rise from about 40,000 to up to 176,000, an increase of about 340%.
What would change
Pre-expansion | Proposed | |
Birds on site at once | about 40,000 | up to 176,000 |
System | free-range | fully indoor |
Length of one cycle (chick in to shed ready again) | 66 days | 49 days |
Cycles per year | about 5.5 | 7 to 7.5 |
Birds raised per year | about 220,000 | about 1.2 to 1.3 million |
Shed floor area | 3,561 m² (internal) | about 10,100 m² internal (four sheds), about 2.8 times today’s; 11,971 m² for all new buildings |
Lorry trips per cycle (each trip is in and out) | 29.5 | 65.5 |
Lorry trips per year | about 162 | about 460 to 490 |
Ammonia per year | about 1,200 kg (Section 3) | about 4,220 kg |
Dust per year | about 4 tonnes (author calculation, same EA factor, Article 3) | about 17.6 tonnes (author calculation, Article 3) |
Litter (used bedding and droppings) per year | about 740 tonnes (author calculation, Article 5) | about 2,750 to 3,100 tonnes (author calculation from the official figure, Article 5) |
The application also includes eight feed silos (each about 9 m tall, higher than the sheds), eight gas tanks, an agricultural storage building, a dead-bird freezer store and other buildings, a new surfaced track, and an infiltration basin† and soakaway to take rainwater from the roofs, yards and access road. Building it would involve about 66,800 tonnes of inert material (soil and demolition rubble), all to be reused on site, over a construction period of about 46 weeks.
Inaccuracies in the paperwork
Bird numbers. The Environmental Statement† gives 176,000 (ES 1.1.1), 173,926 (ES 3.1.4) and 43,182 per shed, which is 172,728 in total (ES 5.1.3). Birds raised per year are given as both 1,223,355 (ES 5.1.8) and 1,232,000 (ES 15.3.2).
Cycle length. The Environmental Statement says birds leave at about 39 days, followed by 7 to 10 days of cleaning, a 49-day cycle and “around 7” crops a year (ES 5.1.2). The odour, dust and ammonia reports say birds are raised to about 38 days, with about 7.5 flocks a year. A 49-day cycle actually gives about 7.4 cycles a year, so the ES’s annual output of about 1.23 million birds is based on fewer flocks than the pollution modelling assumes.
Stocking density. The Environmental Statement (paras 3.1.3 and 18.4.2) and the Design and Access Statement give 30 kg/m², and no other figure. The numbers do not fit it. 176,000 birds of about 2.67 kg (the breeder’s published average for a Ross 308 at 38 days) on 10,108 m² gives about 46.5 kg/m², above the 39 kg/m² legal maximum (33 kg/m², or up to 39 kg/m² if extra conditions are met: Welfare of Farmed Animals (England) Regulations 2007, Schedule 5A). At 30 kg/m², only about 113,500 birds of that weight fit, so about 62,500 birds per crop (35%) would have to be caught and removed several days early. This is called thinning, and it is normal practice at this density. The only mention of it in the application is a line in the EA Odour Management Plan about covering areas where the forklift has worked with shavings “following bird thinning”; how often it happens, how many birds and what it adds are never stated. Each thinning means an extra catch, often at night, with extra lorries and an odour peak, none of it assessed. The alternative, sending every bird at about 1.7 kg (around day 28), does not fit the 38-day growing period in the odour, dust and ammonia reports. The ES also compares its 30 kg/m² with conventional farms at “up to 38 kg/m²” (para 18.4.2).
Who the applicant is. Who the applicant is. The planning application is made by P R & S A Boyles. The Environmental Permit application is made by a company, Higher Meadow Poultry Ltd (company no. 11300805), whose directors are Peter and Samantha Boyles. The Environment Agency’s public consultation names it as “Higher Meadows Poultry Ltd”.
What the application covers. One paragraph says some of the buildings will need a "future planning application". Other paragraphs and the drawings include them in this one. For example, the dead-bird freezer building is drawn (drawing 200 13), although ES para 5.1.4 says ancillary buildings will follow later.
The official description. The council will decide the application on its formal description, which mentions the demolition and rebuilding of four sheds. It does not mention the increase in bird numbers.
Facts, projections, assumptions and promises
It helps to keep four kinds of statement apart when reading the application:
Facts can be checked now. Examples are the size of the sheds, the location, and the distance to the nearest homes.
Projections are what computer models predict, such as odour, ammonia and dust levels at nearby homes. Section 12 explains how these work.
Assumptions are the inputs the projections rely on: bird numbers, cycle length, weather, and where the manure goes.
Promises are what the applicant says it will do, such as avoiding clean-outs when the wind blows towards homes "if at all possible". Section 14 asks which promises could actually be enforced.
The rest of the report keeps these four apart.