top of page

Objecting to the Planning Application

Oct 12
16 min read

Updated: Oct 23

Regarding planning application 82141, Higher Hall Farm, High Bray


Send your objection to North Devon Council (NDC) by 6 November 2026, quoting application 82141 or click this link to go directly to the NDC objection page. The details below give you the facts, the rules and ready-made wording to build your objection.



Key facts



Application number

82141 (Planning Portal ref PP-15123289)

Site

Higher Hall Farm, Holewater Hill, High Bray, EX32 7QN

Applicants

P R and S A Boyles

Proposal

Replace a free-range unit of about 40,000 birds with four sheds housing 176,000 broiler chickens

Comments close

6 November 2026

Case officer

Miss C Roissetter

Expected decision

By a planning officer (delegated), not the Planning Committee

Create your objection by copying from Steps 1, 2 and 3 down below, then pasting and editing the points that are most relevant to your position and experience. How to send your comment

  1. Online: Click here, or

  2. Email: planningcomments@northdevon.gov.uk, with "Objection to 82141" in the subject line.

  3. Post: Strategic Development and Planning, North Devon Council, Lynton House, Commercial Road, Barnstaple, EX31 1DG.


Include your full name and postal address. Comments are usually published on the council website, so write nothing you would not want made public.


The Environment Agency's consultation page for the permit (EPR/FP3722MA/A001) shows no closing date, and no decision has been published. Comments go to pscpublicresponse@environment-agency.gov.uk.


What NDC can and cannot consider

NDC must weigh "material planning considerations". Points outside them are set aside, regardless of how strong they are felt. The application is judged against the adopted North Devon and Torridge Local Plan (2018) and national planning policy.


NDC can consider

Relevant Local Plan policy

NDC cannot consider

Smell, noise, dust, light and loss of enjoyment of homes and gardens

DM01 Amenity Considerations

Loss of property value

Pollution of air, water and land

DM02 Environmental Protection

Private disputes, boundaries, covenants

Construction disruption

DM03 Construction and Environmental Management

Who the applicant is, or their motives

Size, design and appearance of the sheds

DM04 Design Principles

Competition with other businesses

Traffic, road safety and access

DM05 Highways

Matters controlled only by other laws (e.g. animal welfare law), unless they affect land use

Listed buildings and their setting

DM07 Historic Environment; ST15 Conserving Heritage Assets

Moral objections to farming or eating meat

Wildlife and habitats

DM08 Biodiversity and Geodiversity

Petitions or form letters on their own carry little weight

Landscape character, including views to and from Exmoor

DM08A Landscape and Seascape Character; ST14 Enhancing Environmental Assets


Climate change effects

ST02 Mitigating Climate Change


Whether the Environmental Statement is adequate

EIA Regulations 2017



Two things to keep in mind:

  • Odour, dust and ammonia overlap with the EA permit. National policy tells NDC to assume the EA permit will work properly (this list of errors might suggest the application should not have been considered as presented). NDC still decides whether this is an acceptable use of this land, so it can refuse where the effects on neighbours would be unacceptable or the evidence is unreliable. Frame these points as harm to residents and as gaps in the evidence NDC is asked to rely on.

  • Tourism is a valid point; house prices are not. Write about harm to local holiday businesses and the rural economy, never about property values.


Policy titles are from NDC's own decision notices; see the adopted Local Plan for the full wording.



How to write an objection that counts

A few specific, factual points in your own words carry more weight than a long letter. Officers count arguments, not the length of objection.

  1. Use your own words. Identical letters are often treated as one representation. Use the supplied wording below as a starting point and rewrite it.

  2. Say where you live and how you are affected. Your distance from the site, your view of it, your route to school or work, your water supply.

  3. Pick three to six points that affect you. Do not copy every point. A focused letter is read more closely.

  4. Be specific and factual. Quote figures and the document they come from. Say "the odour report models 190 m to the nearest home", not "they lied".

  5. Stay polite and neutral. Criticise the proposal and its evidence, never the applicants personally.

  6. Ask for something. Refusal, or at minimum that NDC asks for missing information before deciding.

  7. Add local knowledge. Fog in the valley, smells you already notice, near-misses on the bridge. Only you can supply this.

  8. Ask your ward councillor If they will request a Planning Committee decision. The application is currently set for an officer decision.

  9. Send it before 6 November Keep a copy. If you email, ask for an acknowledgement.



Step 1: choose an opening

Start with your details and the application, then one opening. Replace everything in [square brackets] or use these to give you an idea how to create your own.

Option A: resident nearby

I live at [address], about [distance] from Higher Hall Farm. I object to application 82141 for four broiler sheds housing 176,000 birds. I am concerned about the effect on my home and on the village, for the reasons below.

I am a parent of a child at Brayford Academy, which is about 380 m from the site boundary measured on Google Earth. I object to application 82141. My concerns are the effects on the school and on the road my child uses every day.

I run [business] at [address]. My business depends on Brayford's quiet, rural setting next to Exmoor. I object to application 82141 because of its likely effect on visitors and on the local economy.

I [live in / regularly visit] the Bray valley. I object to application 82141, which would more than quadruple the number of birds on the site, from about 40,000 to 176,000.



Step 2: choose your points

Each category says why NDC must consider it, then gives sentences to adapt. Figures come from the application documents unless marked as a residents' estimate. Include the points of most concern to you, edit them to make them unique.


Smell (odour)

Counts under DM01 Amenity and DM02 Environmental Protection.


  • The number of birds would rise from about 40,000 to 176,000. I am concerned that smells already noticed at Braycross and High Bray would become more frequent and stronger.

  • The application gives the distance to the nearest home in five different ways: over 500 m, 260 m, 190 m, 180 m and 149 m. The Environment Agency separately identified a converted barn, Exmoor View, about 8 m from the installation boundary. I do not see how NDC can rely on the odour assessment when the nearest home is not clear.

  • Brayford Academy (377 m) is within 400 m of the site but is not listed in the Odour Management Plan.

  • The model assumes the same odour inside each shed for 10,000 birds and for 44,000 birds, and allows only 2 hours per shed for clean-out, while the Odour Management Plan’s 24 hours per house and 48 hours for the site.

  • The Environmental Statement promises clean-out only when the wind blows away from homes. Homes lie to the north-west, north and south-west, so only winds from roughly west to north would avoid all of them.

Counts under DM01 Amenity.


  • The noise report leaves out lorry noise on the basis that traffic will not change, yet the Transport Statement shows lorry trips rising from 29.5 to 65.5 per crop.

  • The Environment Agency noise papers accept that birds will be caught at night, with reversing alarms. With about seven crops a year, I am concerned about regular night-time disturbance.

  • I ask NDC to make sure noise from fans, catching and lorries is assessed at the nearest homes, including Exmoor View Barn.

Counts under DM01 Amenity and DM02 Environmental Protection.


  • There is no bioaerosol assessment, even though a dwelling is within 100 m. The Dust Management Plan refers to a "Bioaerosol Assessment Document" that is not in the application.

  • The dust assessment uses 180 m as the nearest receptor and does not include Exmoor View Barn and does not name the school

  • Residents at Braycross have reported stinging eyes from the existing farm. A unit four times larger raises my concern.

Counts under DM05 Highways.


  • Lorry trips would rise from 29.5 to 65.5 per crop, about 460 a year (residents' estimate from the applicant's 7-cycle figures).

  • The Construction Plan routes lorries from the A361 and A399 through Brayford and past the school. Neither the Environmental Statement nor the Transport Statement assesses this route or the school.

  • The single village road has pinch points and a hump-back bridge. I am concerned for children walking to Brayford Academy.

  • [Add your own experience of the road, e.g. passing places, near-misses, school-run congestion, experience of detours, holiday traffic etc.]

Counts under DM02 Environmental Protection and ST14.


  • The site sits on a Secondary A aquifer with high groundwater vulnerability, in a Nitrate Vulnerable Zone. Rainwater would be drained by infiltration into the ground.

  • Ordnance Survey maps show a well and a spring at Braycross about 250 m downhill, and the Hole Water stream about 345 m away. Some homes nearby may rely on private water supplies, and these are not identified in the application.

  • The Lead Local Flood Authority had not commented when this guide was written. I ask NDC to wait for its response.

  • [If you have a private water supply, say where it is and that you are concerned about contamination.]

Counts under DM02 Environmental Protection.


  • The documents give five different answers on where manure would go: an anaerobic digestion plant (EA form), spreading by contractors (Manure Management Statement), neighbouring farms (EA contingency plan), the operator's own land (EA closure plan) and field heaps (EA fugitive emissions). No digestion plant is named.

  • The Environmental Statement declines to assess manure spreading, calling it "conjecture". Residents estimate the unit would produce around 1,700 to 3,100 tonnes of litter a year.

  • Devon County Council (Waste) has said the Waste Audit Statement is incomplete.

Counts under DM04 Design, DM07 Historic Environment, DM08A Landscape, ST14 and ST15.


  • Four sheds, each about 24 m by 104 m, would be built on a hillside next to Exmoor National Park. There is no landscape and visual impact assessment.

  • The Grade I listed Church of All Saints and six other listed buildings are within 1 km. The Environmental Statement says none are affected but does not assess their setting.

  • Devon County Council's Historic Environment team has asked for a written scheme of archaeological investigation.

Counts under DM08 Biodiversity and ST14.


  • The ammonia report appears to overstate today's emissions about 3.6 times. It applies two emission factors in full where Environment Agency guidance gives a single combined factor. Corrected, ammonia from the site would rise about 3.5 times, not stay the same.

  • Background ammonia at nearby woodland is already 1.24 µg/m³, above the 1 µg/m³ critical level for lichens and mosses. The farm alone would add up to about 80% of that level.

  • The report relies on a Natural England exemption for schemes that reduce emissions. If the reduction comes from the factor error, the exemption may not apply.

Counts under DM01 Amenity Considerations (living conditions of residents and guests) and DM02 Environmental Protection (odour and flies). Lorries on the village road also count under DM05 Highways. National policy supporting the rural economy applies too.


  • Exmoor View Barn, on the applicant's land, is advertised on Airbnb as a holiday let sleeping four, yet the Dust Management Plan calls it a "staff dwelling". I ask the applicant to clarify how it will be used and, if it stays a holiday let, to include it in the assessments.

  • If the applicant expects holiday guests would not wish to stay so close to the sheds, that is relevant to other holiday accommodation nearby.

  • The Environmental Statement says “considerable tolerance of odour may develop, particularly in rural communities” (ES 8.3.3). That suggests residents may get used to the smell over time. It also concedes that the smell is noticeable to begin with. Holiday guests, walkers and wedding parties would be hit by the smell each time they visit.

  • Holiday accommodation and venues around the parish include Acorn Retreat and The Penny Lilac (Brayford); Old Church House (High Bray); Little Bray House (with fishing rights), Little Bray camping grounds (Little Bray); and The Barns at Withygate, a new wedding venue. They depend on a quiet rural setting, clean air (considering the reliance on Exmoor as a natural countryside destination) and good reviews.

  • The applicant’s own odour model predicts odour rising at Withygate, where The Barns operates as a wedding venue. A wedding day spoilt by smell cannot be put right afterwards, and one poor review can cost future bookings.

  • Near other broiler units, residents report being unable to sit outside, open windows or dry washing. It is often worst in summer and when wind funnels the smell along a valley. Here the gable fans face west and the site is in a valley, so the outdoor setting visitors come for would be the first thing affected.

  • Flies are a recurring complaint near broiler units, especially at clean-out. In Torridge, the neighbouring district, the operator of a poultry unit at Milton Damerel was prosecuted under its permit over flies (source). Here litter would be removed at every clean-out, seven times a year, about 149 m from the nearest homes.

  • At Penhros, a unit of similar size, a neighbour moved bedrooms because of catching lorries in the early hours (source and source). At Brayford about 40 of the 65.5 lorry visits per crop fall in weeks 5 and 6, and the operator’s own Environment Agency papers say catching “frequently” happens at night. Guests in nearby holiday lets or along thre road would be exposed to this.

  • I ask NDC to treat the holiday accommodation and the wedding venue as sensitive receptors, and to require the odour, noise and fly effects on them to be assessed before a decision. and good reviews.


Counts under the EIA Regulations 2017: NDC must not grant permission without adequate environmental information, and can ask for more under Regulation 25. Residents have logged dozens of contradictions in the application. These are the strongest, with references so officers can check them. Pick two or three, and say what you want done about them.


The nearest buildings and receptors

  • The Environment Agency asked for Exmoor View Barn to be included in the assessments (EA letter, 12 August 2026). The odour, noise and dust reports submitted to NDC still leave it out.

  • The nearest home is given as 260 m (ES 3.3.1), over 500 m (ES 10.2.2), 190 m (odour report), 180 m (dust report) and 149 m (EA odour and noise plans). The Environmental Statement's "low impact" ratings rest on the largest of these.


What is actually being applied for

  • Bird numbers are given as 176,000 (ES 1.1.1), 173,926 (ES 3.1.4) and 172,728 (ES 5.1.3). Crops per year are given as 7 (ES 5.1.2) and 7.5 (odour and ammonia reports). A scheme that states its own size several ways cannot be assessed or controlled by condition.

  • The ancillary buildings, including a 1,250 m² store, are shown on the drawings (ES 3.1.5), but ES 5.1.4 says they "will be provided as part of a future planning application". It is unclear what NDC is being asked to approve.

  • The Environmental Statement states 30 kg/m² (ES 3.1.3), but 176,000 birds on 10,108 m² at a normal finishing weight would reach about 44 kg/m², above the 39 kg/m² legal maximum (residents' calculation). Meeting the stated density would mean removing about a third of the birds early. Thinning is not mentioned anywhere, so its extra catching nights and lorries are not assessed.


Noise and odour

  • The noise report treats the gable-end fans as emergency-only, so assesses them as rarely running. Yet the ES (5.1.13) says they are for summer use, and the odour, dust and ammonia models assume they run whenever it is above 23°C. These are the loudest fans (64 dB(A) against 49 dB(A) at 7 m).

  • The noise report says transport will not change (noise report s2; ES 9.3.4), while the applicant's own figures show lorry trips per crop more than doubling, from 29.5 to 65.5.

  • The EA noise assessment says birds are "frequently" caught at night, but the noise report does not assess night catching.

  • The ES's main odour conclusion relies on the H4 benchmarks (ES 8.1.1), which the Environment Agency withdrew in December 2025.


Land, water and wildlife

  • The site is described as "level ground" (EA site condition report), but the survey shows levels from about 194 m to 218 m, with up to about 5 m of fill under the eastern sheds.

  • The nearest watercourse is given three ways: a ditch on the site (ES 7.1.3), over 200 m away (construction plan 2.1), and none within 20 m (application form). Pollution routes to the River Bray cannot be assessed without it.

  • The ES does not mention groundwater, though the EA site condition report records high groundwater vulnerability on a Secondary A aquifer. Yard water is to soak into this ground.

  • The application form says there are no trees, hedges or habitats on or near the site. The applicant's own ecology report (5.2.1) records 129 m of priority hedgerow and 0.25 ha of woodland lost, and the EA screening shows ancient woodland within 250 m.

  • The ecology report gives two grid references about 1.3 km apart for the site (summary and 2.2.1).

  • The ES says the site has no archaeological interest (ES 14.3.1). Devon County Council's archaeology team says the western land is undisturbed and needs investigation (28 September 2026).


Waste

  • Odour Management Plan says “Twice weekly collection” of carcasses. The Transport Statement allows one collection every two crops, about 98 days. A 4 m × 4 m cold store building would then need to hold up to about 10,500 carcasses, with no assessment of its capacity, power back-up or smell.

  • The manure destination is given five different ways across the documents (see category 6).


Missing assessments

  • ES chapter 20, "Alternative Sites", discusses need only. No other sites, sizes or layouts are compared, although the EIA Regulations require the main alternatives studied to be described (Schedule 4, paragraph 2).

  • There is no cumulative assessment. The section headed "Cumulative" (ES 12.3) only compares the existing farm with the proposed one, and a scheme for 14 or more homes about 260 m away is not considered.

  • Some documents contain template text from other sites, such as references to biomass fuel, a mains gas meter and the "North Devon and Teignbridge Local Plan" (DAS 4.4–4.5).


What is being applied for

The application describes itself as an expansion, yet parts of the project are left for later. ES 5.1.4 says the ancillary buildings “will be provided as part of a future planning application”, (200 12–15) shows a “Heating/Pyrolysis Building” that is not assessed, and no destination is confirmed for an estimated 1,700–2,100 tonnes of manure a year. EIA requires the whole project to be assessed now. If permission is granted, I ask that conditions limit bird numbers, crops per year and buildings to those assessed.


What to ask for

I ask NDC to require the applicant, under Regulation 25 of the EIA Regulations, to correct these errors and fill these gaps, and to consult the public again on the corrected information before any decision.




Step 3: choose a closing

End with what you want NDC to do. Then sign with your name and date.


Option A: ask for refusal

For these reasons I believe the proposal conflicts with policies DM01, DM02 and DM05 of the North Devon and Torridge Local Plan, and I ask the Council to refuse application 82141.

I ask the Council to refuse this application. If it is minded to approve, I ask that it first requires the applicant to correct the errors and gaps in the Environmental Statement, and consults the public again on the corrected information.

Given the scale of the proposal and the level of local concern, I ask that this application is decided by the Planning Committee rather than by officers, and that I am told the date of the meeting so I can attend.

I ask the Council to refuse this application. Thank you for considering my comments. Please acknowledge receipt.

The proposal would harm the living conditions of residents and visitors, and the rural tourism businesses that depend on them, contrary to policies DM01 and DM02 of the North Devon and Torridge Local Plan. I ask the Council to refuse application 82141.


Evidence must be presented now

Once a unit is built, problems are hard to put right. This is why errors in the assessments matter before a decision, not after.

  • The courts have quashed a similar permission. In R (Squire) v Shropshire Council [2019] EWCA Civ 888, Shropshire Council approved four broiler sheds about 300 yards from a home, producing about 2,322 tonnes of manure a year. The Environmental Statement did not assess odour and dust from storing and spreading that manure. The Court of Appeal found the assessment "incomplete and unlawful" and quashed the permission. It held that neither the EA permit nor a later manure agreement filled the gap (summary).

  • Other units show the same pattern. Residents near broiler units elsewhere report smell indoors and out, swarms of flies lasting months, and lorries in the early hours. At Fulmodeston the council served an abatement notice over flies (source). These problems are far easier to prevent than to fix.

  • Fixes after approval are limited. At Newbridge Farm poultry unit, East Huntspill, Somerset, the Environment Agency substantiated residents' odour complaints after the unit grew. The operator tried changing feed and reducing bird numbers, and taller chimneys were refused planning permission (press report, March 2018).

  • Residents' remedies are slow. After approval, residents can complain to the Environment Agency or pursue statutory nuisance. An operator can defend a nuisance claim by showing it uses the "best practicable means" to limit smell, even if the smell continues (Environmental Protection Act 1990, s80).


You can use these as background. Your objection should focus on this application's own errors; one sentence citing Squire under manure (listed in Step 2) is enough.



Common questions

These answers reflect normal council practice. Check with NDC Planning if you want to be sure.


Someone in my household has already objected. Can I object too?

Yes. Every adult can object in their own name, and each letter counts separately. Write your own letter in your own words: identical letters from one address may be treated as a single comment. If you share an email address, one person can use the online form and the other can email planningcomments@northdevon.gov.uk.


I have already objected. Can I add to or change my comments?

Yes. To add points, send a further comment quoting 82141, headed "Additional comments". Both will be considered. To replace your comment, email planningcomments@northdevon.gov.uk for the case officer, quoting 82141 and the date of your first comment, and ask for it to be withdrawn and replaced by the attached version.


Do I have to live in the village to object?

No. Anyone can comment, and NDC must consider every valid planning point. What counts is what you say, not where you live. Visitors can speak of tourism and the Exmoor setting, people who use the road to traffic and safety, and local groups (the parish council, CPRE Devon, angling clubs, wildlife trusts) add weight. Say what your link to the area is. Template comments with no local link carry the least weight.


What if I miss 6 November?

Comments received before a decision is made are usually still considered, but this is not guaranteed. Aim to send yours before the deadline. Check before you send

Follow this list so your objection is properly considered:

  • Application number 82141 in the subject line

  • Your full name and postal address included

  • Points rewritten in your own words

  • At least one detail only you could know (where you live, what you see, smell or hear)

  • Nothing about property values or the applicants personally

  • Sent before 6 November 2026, with a copy kept

  • Ward councillor asked about a committee decision




Sources




 
 
bottom of page