Response: re. Ecological Appraisal
Summary of email from Mark Saunders to Chloe Roissetter 23/09/2026
What it states
Existing Site & Context
Total area: The existing site covers approximately 3.96ha.
Current habitats: Features grassland, young mixed woodland, scrub, poultry sheds, and hedge banks.
Surrounding landscape: Encircled by open countryside, with dense woodland to the east.
Species value: Rated as moderate value for protected species.
Surveys: The Ecological Appraisal confirms no further surveys are needed.
Operational Changes
System shift: Transitions from an existing free-range system to standard housed broiler production.
Habitat benefit: This shift significantly decreases degradation on adjacent habitats.
Design status: Detailed Landscape Plans and planting specifications are already submitted and deemed appropriate.
Net Gain Calculations
Area habitats: Delivers a 15.33% Biodiversity Net Gain.
Linear habitats: Delivers a 12.93% Biodiversity Net Gain for hedgerows.
Specific Habitat Losses
Grassland: Loss of 2.03ha poor modified grassland and 0.25ha poor neutral grassland.
Scrub: Loss of 0.44ha poor mixed scrub and 0.1ha bramble scrub.
Woodland: Loss of 0.25ha poor mixed woodland.
Hedgerow: Loss of 130m good species-rich native hedgerow with bank.
Specific Habitat Gains
Enhancement: Upgrades 0.44ha of poor modified grassland to moderate neutral grassland.
New grassland: Creates 0.46ha moderate neutral grassland and 0.055ha moderate modified grassland.
New drainage: Creates 0.18ha moderate SUDS and 0.06ha moderate bioswale.
New woodland & trees: Creates 0.37ha moderate broadleaved woodland and 15 moderate small rural trees.
New scrub: Creates 0.35ha good mixed scrub.
New hedgerow: Creates 310m good species-rich native hedgerow with bank.
What it asks for
1. Ecological & Operational Constraints
Vegetation Clearance: No removal of hedgerows, trees, or shrubs between 1st March and 31st August inclusive, unless a competent ecologist verifies the absence of active birds' nests immediately prior to clearance.
External Lighting: Must be strictly limited in accordance with the Ecological Appraisal (EA) and GN08 Bats and Artificial Lighting guidelines.
2. Submission & Procedural Timelines
Biodiversity Gain Plan (BGP): Must be submitted in writing to the LPA no earlier than the day after planning permission is granted. The LPA has 8 weeks to issue a decision. Use of the national template is strongly encouraged.
Habitat Management & Monitoring Plan (HMMP): Must be secured by condition and submitted alongside the BGP. It must establish a monitoring and management framework lasting at least 30 years, outline remediation measures, and schedule periodic monitoring reports with photographic evidence for the LPA.
3. Mandatory BGP Content (Non-Phased Development)
Under Schedule 7A of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990 and the 2015 Development Management Procedure Order, the BGP must include:
Project Details: Name/address of the compiler and submitter, description of development, and the planning reference number.
Metrics & Dates: The relevant baseline date (with justification if an earlier date is used), completed metric tool calculations (showing publication date, pre-, and post-development values), and scaled pre- and post-development habitat plans showing North.
Impact & Mitigation: Steps taken to minimise adverse biodiversity impacts, a description of how the biodiversity gain hierarchy was followed (with reasons for any deviations), and 30-year maintenance/monitoring arrangements.
Offsite Gains & Credits: Details of any registered off-site biodiversity gains allocated or biodiversity credits purchased.
Special Declarations (If Applicable):
Compensation arrangements for irreplaceable habitats. If prior habitat degradation occurred, a statement confirming this, the pre-degradation date, the corresponding metric calculation, and supporting evidence.
What it says
The submitted Ecological Appraisal (EA) concludes that the existing site is approximately 3.96ha of grassland, young mixed woodland, scrub and existing poultry sheds bounded by hedge banks. The site is surrounded by open countryside and heavily wooded areas to the east. Onsite habitats are considered of moderate value for protected species, and no further survey effort is considered necessary. No removal of hedgerows, trees or shrubs should take place between 1st March and 31st August inclusive, unless a competent ecologist has undertaken a careful, detailed check of vegetation for active birds’ nests immediately before the vegetation is cleared. External lighting should be strictly limited in accordance with the EA and GN08 Bats and Artificial Lighting. The submitted BNG Metric concludes that the existing habitats are of moderate ecological value currently and that the proposed development will result in a 15.33% BNG for area habitats and 12.93% for linear habitats. Approximately 2.03ha of poor condition modified grassland, 0.1ha of bramble scrub, 0.44ha of poor condition mixed scrub, 0.25ha of poor condition other neutral grassland, 0.25ha of poor condition other mixed woodland and 130m of good condition species rich native hedgerow with bank will be lost as a result of the proposed development. A further 0.44ha of poor condition modified grassland will be enhanced to moderate condition other neutral grassland. The proposed development will also result in the creation of 0.055ha of moderate condition modified grassland, 0.46ha of moderate condition other neutral grassland, 0.18ha of moderate condition SUDS, 0.06ha moderate condition bioswale, 0.35ha of good condition mixed scrub, 0.37ha of moderate condition broadleaved woodland, and 15 moderate condition small rural trees. A further 310m of good condition species rich native hedgerow with bank will be created. The proposed landscaping specification appears appropriate as the applicant seeks to move from the existing free-range system to a standard housed broiler production. This will result in significantly decreased degradation on the proposed adjacent habitats. Detailed Landscape Plans and planting specifications reflecting the BNG Metric have been submitted. A habitat management and monitoring plan (HMMP) in accordance with the EA, BNG Metric and Landscape Plans must be secured by condition to ensure an appropriate monitoring and reporting framework is in place for at least 30 years and should be submitted alongside the Biodiversity Gain Plan (BGP). The HMMP will be required to clearly set out the implementation and future management of all ‘significant’ onsite habitats in order to ensure that the strategy is effective in the long term and should include appropriate remediation measures where required. The HMMP must include a schedule for the delivery of monitoring reports with photographic evidence periodically to the LPA. A BNG monitoring fee of £4,131.08 should be secured in accordance with the Devon County Council monitoring calculation to cover costs of agreeing the Biodiversity Gain Plan and detailed Habitat Management and Monitoring Plan and monitoring significant onsite BNG. 2 The BGP will be required in order to discharge the statutory BGP condition under paragraph 13 of Schedule 7A of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990. The BGP condition will not be included on the decision note. The BGP discharging the BGP Condition must be submitted to the LPA in writing, no earlier than the day after planning permission has been granted. The use of the national BGP template is strongly encouraged to bring together the required information into one document for approval. There is no separate application form for the submission of the BGP. As with the discharge of other conditions which require approval of LPA planning authorities will have 8 weeks to approve the BGP (unless another timescale is agreed). The following content of a BGP is required for development which is not to proceed in phases. Where planning permission is granted that has the effect of permitting development in phases, there are different requirements for the BGP. Under paragraph 14(2) of Schedule 7A, a BGP must include the following matters: - information about the steps taken or to be taken to minimise the adverse effect of the development on the biodiversity of the onsite habitat and any other habitat; - the pre-development biodiversity value of the onsite habitat; - the post-development biodiversity value of the onsite habitat; - any registered off-site biodiversity gain allocated to the development and the biodiversity; and - any biodiversity credits purchased for the development. In addition, under Articles 37C(2) and 37C(4) of The Town and Country Planning (Development Management Procedure) (England) Order 2015, the following specified matters are required, where development is not to proceed in phases: - name and address of the person completing the Plan, and (if different) the person submitting the Plan; - a description of the development and planning permission reference number (to which the plan relates); - the relevant date, for the purposes of calculating the pre-development biodiversity value of onsite habitats and if proposing an earlier date, the reasons for using this earlier date; - the completed biodiversity metric calculation tool(s), stating the publication date of the tool(s), and showing the calculation of the pre-development onsite value on the relevant date, and postdevelopment biodiversity value; - a description of arrangements for maintenance and monitoring of habitat enhancement to which paragraph 9(3) of Schedule 7A to the 1990 Act applies (habitat enhancement which must be maintained for at least 30 years after the development is completed); - (except for onsite irreplaceable habitats) a description of how the biodiversity gain hierarchy will be followed and where to the extent any actions (in order of priority) in that hierarchy are not followed and the reason for that; - pre-development and post-development plans showing the location of onsite habitat (including any irreplaceable habitat) on the relevant date, and drawn to an identified scale and showing the direction of North; - a description of any irreplaceable habitat on the land to which the plan relates which exist on the relevant date, and any part of the development for which planning permission is granted where the onsite habitat of that part is irreplaceable habitat arrangements for compensation for any impact the development has on the biodiversity of the irreplaceable habitat; and if habitat degradation has taken place: a statement to this effect, - the date immediately before the degradation activity, - the completed biodiversity tool showing the calculation of the biodiversity value of the onsite habitat on that date, and 3 - any available supporting evidence for the value.