Summary
Updated: Oct 14
For an even simpler summary click here.
ABOUT AMMONIA
Health: irritates eyes, nose and throat, and helps form fine particles (PM2.5) linked to heart and lung disease.
Odour: adds to the sharp smell from sheds and litter.
Wildlife: damages the mosses and lichens on trees. The background level here is already above the limit for ancient woodland such as Barton Woods.
Over-fertilising: nitrogen settling on woodland favours nettles and brambles over native plants. The background here is nearly three times the limit.
Acidification: the background acid deposition already exceeds the limit the Environment Agency set for Barton Woods.
Water: run-off adds nutrients to streams and is toxic to fish. The site is in a Nitrate Vulnerable Zone.
How the terrain affects dispersion
The site sits on a col at about 200–220 m, with land falling towards Brayford, the River Bray and Hole Water.
Windy days: the exposed position spreads emissions. The prevailing south-west wind carries them towards the Holewater Hill and Withygate rather than Brayford.
Calm nights: cold air flows downhill, carrying emissions into the valleys and village, where they collect under a temperature inversion and remain trapped.
Mornings: pollution trapped overnight can drop to ground level when the inversion breaks.
Modelling: coarse weather data from a global forecast model, a setting that makes the model behave more like flat ground, and calm hours left out of the ammonia run mean these conditions are poorly captured.
The figures presented for ammonia The applicantion claims emissions will fall by 2.2%. But the application double-counts the current farm’s ammonia, making it look about 3.6 times worse than it is, so the new sheds look like an improvement. On the Environment Agency’s own factors, ammonia would rise from about 1,200 kg to 4,224 kg a year: an increase of 252%, or about 3.5 times as much.
AMMONIA CONCLUSION
The author believes the predictions understate the effects on residents and the countryside. The application's own figures imply that emissions would fall by about 2.2%; corrected, ammonia rises by about 250%. The model includes the hills, but it uses coarse regional weather data, leaves out calm hours altogether, and overrides the setting normally used for hilly ground, so the air mixes as it would over flat land. No results with the normal setting are provided. The report gives the farm’s contribution only, never the total with background levels that already exceed the limits for nearby ancient woodland, and it does not name Barton Woods or assess acid deposition, both of which the Environment Agency asked for. With ammonia adding to the smell, forming fine particles in the air and damaging woodland that is already over its limits, a 250% rise is not something the village or the countryside can absorb, especially in consideration of emmissions over years.
ODOUR
Nature: intensive livestock odour is classed as “moderately offensive”. It comes mainly from droppings, wet litter, feed and dead birds.
When it is worst: odour builds through each crop. It is strongest in the last week or two, when the birds are heaviest, and peaks again at clean-out.
More clean-outs: shorter cycles mean about 28 to 30 shed clean-outs a year instead of about 22. The applicant’s own permit papers rate odour exposure during clean-out as “Likely”.
Daily life: odour decides whether people open windows, hang out washing, sit outside or walk the lanes. It is worst on warm evenings, when the fans run hardest.
Health and wellbeing: strong, repeated odour is linked with annoyance, stress, headaches and disturbed sleep.
How Brayford’s terrain affects dispersion
The site sits on a col at about 200–220 m, with land falling towards Brayford, the River Bray and Hole Water.
Windy days: the prevailing south-west wind carries odour towards Exmoor View, Catkins and the Holewater Hill homes. An easterly wind carries it from the west-facing fans of Sheds 1 and 2 towards Braycross and Brayford.
Calm nights: on clear, still nights a temperature inversion (warmer air sitting above cooler air) acts like a lid on the valley. Odour stays close to the ground, barely diluted, and drains downhill with cold air into the valleys and village. This can follow hot days, when the fans have run hardest and windows are open.
Mornings: when the sun breaks the inversion, odour held overnight can reach ground level all at once, often as people open up their homes.
Modelling: the model includes the hills, but it uses coarse regional weather data and treats each hour separately, so it cannot show odour building up overnight. The consultant applied a setting that makes the model behave more like flat ground, so the air mixes as it would over flat land. By the consultant’s own account, this lowers predictions for the new sheds’ high roof fans, particularly overnight, and no results with the normal setting are provided.
Judging odour
The applicant’s case is that no home would exceed 3.0 odour units, a benchmark from the Environment Agency’s H4 guidance. H4 was withdrawn in December 2025 and replaced with guidance that sets no numerical limits. The applicant’s consultant says this leaves “no guidance on what level of odour might be problematic”. Even under H4, the benchmark ignored the worst 175 hours a year: the very nights residents will notice most.
Odour is now judged on its real-world effect on people, not on a single modelled number. The common approach, also set out in the applicant’s own odour report, is known as FIDOR:
Frequency: how often the smell occurs
Intensity: how strong it is
Duration: how long each episode lasts
Offensiveness: how unpleasant the type of smell is
Receptor sensitivity: who is exposed, such as homes, a school, or holiday lets
On every one of these, the application is weak. Odour would peak at the end of each crop and at 28 to 30 clean-outs a year. Still nights would let it build up in the valley. It is classed as “moderately offensive”. And the nearest building, a holiday let, and the village school are not assessed at all.
Under the new guidance:
Modelling counts for less: dispersion modelling is one optional tool among several. Yet the applicant’s odour case rests almost entirely on modelling against the withdrawn 3.0 benchmark.
The management plan counts for more: the test is whether the operator uses appropriate measures, set out in its odour management plan. The applicant’s plan:
says activities are kept away from homes “to the east”, when the nearest homes are north and north-west
leaves out Exmoor View, which the Environment Agency asked about
promises to avoid clean-outs in the wrong wind only “if at all possible”.
Weekly sniff test: the only odour monitoring is a weekly check at the site boundary by “a person not directly involved with the poultry”, which could include someone living or working on the farm. A nose surrounded by the smell all day adapts to it. Neighbours experience it differently. Odour rises and falls with the wind, the crop cycle and clean-outs, and when people walk near the site or past fields that may be spread with litter, so each odour event is noticed afresh, repeatedly through each crop. As the applicant’s own odour report says, “a fluctuating odour is often more noticeable than a steady background odour”. No training, screening, timing, wind direction or test points are set, and results are recorded by the operator and kept on site, so the applicant would in effect be marking its own homework.
Complaints matter more, but only once the farm is running: complaint handling now carries more weight, but residents can only complain once they are already living with the smell. The application itself suggests “considerable tolerance of odour may develop”, which in effect means residents will get used to it.
The figures presented for odour
The model predicts odour at Braycross Cottages would fall from 5.57 today to 2.15 with the new sheds. Neither figure is reliable:
Today’s figure is too high: the model treats the existing paddocks as smelling at full strength every hour of every day, all year round. The consultant admits this is “probably rather precautionary”.
The new figure is too low: the model assumes a shed of 44,000 birds smells no stronger inside than one of 10,000, allows only 2 hours of clean-out per shed against the 7 to 10 days in the Environmental Statement, and uses the flat-ground setting. Overstating today and understating tomorrow makes the “improvement” look far bigger than it is.
Rises: odour goes up at The Bungalow, Beara Hill and Withygate.
Not modelled: Exmoor View, 8 m from the boundary, and Brayford Academy.
No binding limit: there is no enforceable odour limit at any home.
ODOUR CONCLUSION
The author believes the odour case does not stand up. Its central claim is measured against a benchmark the Environment Agency has withdrawn. It uses a yearly figure that leaves out the very nights and mornings when most residents would notice the smell, when inversions trap odour in the valley and release it at dawn. The predicted improvement rests on assumptions that favour the new sheds, and the nearest building and the school are not assessed at all. Under the new guidance, the real protection is the odour management plan, and this one points the wrong way, omits the nearest property and relies on a "weekly sniff test". The council is not obliged to accept this application: it decides whether the location is suitable, and the evidence here shows the odour case is unreliable and the safeguards weak, therefore the effect on the community is greater. The author believes these strong reasons to refuse. If permission were nonetheless granted, binding odour limits and independent monitoring at nearby homes would be essential; otherwise residents’ only protection would be the operator’s own sniff test and complaints made after the smell is suffered.
ABOUT DUST
Composition: bedding, feed, dried droppings, feather and skin fragments, bacteria, moulds, and toxic substances from bacteria (endotoxins). Much of it is fine particles (PM10 and PM2.5) small enough to reach deep into the lungs.
Amenity: settled dust soils cars, windowsills, windows, garden furniture and washing.
Background: local fine-particle levels are already more than half the 2040 legal target. Brayford Quarry is a separate dust source that is not assessed alongside this proposal.
Water: dust from the fans settles on roofs and yards and is washed into the drainage that soaks into the ground.
Health effects
Airways: dust and endotoxins can cause coughing, wheezing and irritation of the nose and throat, and can inflame the airways.
Asthma and allergies: short peaks can trigger asthma attacks, and mould spores and feather proteins can cause allergic reactions.
Heart and lungs: long-term exposure to fine particles is linked with heart and lung disease. Official guidance treats PM2.5 as having no known safe level.
Lung function: research on people living near intensive livestock farms in the Netherlands found small reductions in lung function linked to farm emissions.
Vulnerable people: children, older people and anyone with asthma or a heart or lung condition are most at risk, particularly from short peaks.
Evidence caveat: the composition of poultry dust comes from a Health and Safety Executive review that the applicant’s own dust report cites. Most evidence of health effects comes from farm workers, who are exposed to far higher levels than neighbours. This information illustrates what poultry dust can do; it is not a statement that this proposal will cause these effects.
Terrain and dust dispersion
The heavier dust settles close to the sheds. The finest particles travel like a gas and follow the same paths as ammonia.
Windy days: the prevailing south-west wind carries dust towards Exmoor View and the Holewater Hill homes.
Calm nights: fine dust drains downhill with cold air and collects in the valleys and village under a temperature inversion.
Mornings: dust trapped overnight can reach ground level when the inversion breaks.
Modelling: the model includes the hills, but uses coarse regional weather data and treats each hour separately, so it does not show dust building up in still air or draining down the valley overnight. The consultant also overrode the setting normally used for hilly ground, so the air mixes as it would over flat land. The reason given is that the terrain is not steep enough to need it, yet the same report describes “deeply incised river valleys”, and no results with the normal setting are provided.
The figures presented for dust
At the Environment Agency’s standard rate, the birds would release about 17.6 tonnes of dust a year. That total is the author’s calculation, not a figure the applicant gives. The application says no annual air-quality limit would be broken at any of the homes and buildings assessed, but it admits the 24-hour limit may be exceeded close to the gable end fans.
The assessment leaves out:
dust from clean-out and loading litter
the quarry
Exmoor View, 8 m from the boundary and the nearest property to those fans.
No dust or bioaerosol monitoring is proposed. The bioaerosol assessment the dust plan relies on has not been seen.
DUST CONCLUSION
The author believes the predictions may understate residential exposure, particularly during short peaks and at the nearest properties. The model assumes dust is released at a steady rate, although emissions peak late in each crop, in hot weather and at clean-out, so exposure rises at exactly those times. The consultant warns its short-term results “should only be used comparatively”. Clean-out, litter loading, the quarry and Exmoor View are left out, and no dust monitoring is proposed to check the predictions once the farm is running.
MANURE
What it is: used bedding mixed with droppings and feathers, cleared from the sheds after every crop. It is the farm’s largest waste stream and a major source of ammonia, odour, flies and water pollution.
How much: How much: the applicant gives no figure. On official figures and a lower estimate from a comparable farm, it would be between about 1,700 and 3,100 tonnes a year.
Clean-out: each shed is emptied 7 to 7.5 times a year, about 28 to 30 shed clean-outs. Dust and odour from loading the litter are not assessed.
Where would it go?
The application gives six different answers, and none of them is binding:
sold to an anaerobic digestion (AD) plant (ES, permit form, Site Condition Report)
spread locally by third parties (Manure Management Statement)
used on “operator controlled land” or sold (Site Closure Plan)
removed by neighbouring farms (Contingencies)
stored in “temporary field heaps” (Fugitive Emissions)
not listed as a waste at all (Waste Assessment and Waste Management Plan).
No AD plant is named, no contract is shown, and no fields are identified. The Manure Management Statement itself calls the details “assumptions only”.
Why it matters
Water: the area is a Nitrate Vulnerable Zone. Spreading must keep 50 m from springs and wells and 10 m from watercourses, and stay within nitrogen limits. None of this can be checked without named fields.
Odour and flies: Spread litter smells most strongly in the first hours and days. On grassland, where it cannot be ploughed in, the smell can linger for several days, longer in damp or still weather. Field heaps can smell for as long as they stand, for up to a year. heaps can also breed flies, which the applicant’s own Fugitive Emissions document acknowledges.
Traffic: If the litter goes to local farms, it would move by tractor and trailer, about 115 to 140 loads a year on the author’s estimate, on the same lanes.
The law: in Squire v Shropshire (2019), the Court of Appeal quashed permission for a poultry unit because manure spread on unidentified third-party land had not been assessed. The court called the assessment “incomplete and unlawful”.
MANURE CONCLUSION
The author believes the application cannot be properly assessed while it says neither how much manure there would be nor where it would go. Thousands of tonnes a year are left to “assumptions”, with no named destination, no fields and no binding plan. The council should require a fixed, assessed manure route before deciding the application. THese being the same grounds as the Court of Appeal squashing an application.
Everything in the manure section is drawn from the applicant’s documents and the Squire judgment. The tonnage and tractor-load figures are author estimates.
OTHER POLLUTIONS
Noise: fans run day and night in a very quiet valley. The noise assessment leaves out lorries, night catching, the generator and pressure washers.
Light: security and catching lights after dark, with no mention of the Exmoor Dark Sky Reserve.
Water: run-off soaks into highly vulnerable groundwater inside a Drinking Water Protected Area. Wells and springs exist downstream. Chemicals and diesel are stored on site, and no monitoring is proposed.
Greenhouse gases: not quantified, although the EIA rules require it.
Flies: wet litter and field heaps can breed flies, numerous complaint examples can be found with a Google search. The pest management plan the application relies on has not been found.
OTHER POLLUTION CONCLUSION
The author believes these effects are left out or dismissed without evidence. They fall on the same homes, lanes and water as ammonia, dust and odour, yet nothing considers their combined effect on residents, amenity or the environment.
TRAFFIC
Road safety: about three times as many heavy lorries would use a narrow lane shared with children, walkers, cyclists and horse riders.
Pinch points: there are numerous narrow sections along the route, particularly at The Old Post Office, at the bridge, at THe Old Baptist Chapel, and where the road leaves the A399. A 28-tonne feed lorry meeting a car, farm traffic or other HGV means someone reversing to a passing place (assuming there is one that can accommodate multiple vehicles).
Homes on the lane: several properties front directly onto the road, so every lorry passes within feet of their doors and windows.
School and village hall: Brayford Academy and the village hall, which hosts the pre-school, are on the same road. Lorries potentially pass at drop-off and pick-up times.
Night disturbance: bird-catching lorries run at night, and no limit on lorry hours is proposed.
Wear and damage: nothing assesses the bridge, soft verges or the road surface for repeated heavy loads.
The route and alternatives
The construction plan routes vehicles from the A361 onto the A399 and through Brayford, past the school. The Transport Statement does not name a route at all.
The A399 is vulnerable to closure and restriction:
In 2010 it was shut for a month north of Brayford to rebuild collapsed retaining walls.
In late 2025 the stretch between Bray Barn and Newtown Bridge ran under temporary traffic lights for a month while the cliff face was investigated.
Residents report frequent temporary restrictions after flooding and storms.
The signed lorry diversion for the 2010 closure was a long one: A399 to Aller Cross, the A361 to Barnstaple, then Bratton Fleming, Four Cross Way and back to the A399.
If the lane between the farm and the A399 is blocked, the only other ways out are minor roads via Yarde Down: south to North Molton and South Molton, or north-east across open moorland to Simonsbath. These have tight bends and few passing places, and are unsuitable for heavy traffic in any volume.
Nothing in the application says where lorries would go when the A399 or the village lane is closed or restricted.
The figures presented for traffic
The applicant’s Transport Statement gives:
Trips per cycle | Two-way movements | |
Today (66-day cycle) | 29.5 | 59 |
Proposed (49-day cycle) | 65.5 | 131 |
Across a year that is about 459 to 488 trips under the proposal, an increase of between approximately 180 and 200%. Residents see about 320 lorry passes a year today and about 920 to 980 under the proposal.
The Statement calls this “approximately 1 trip per day”, but deliveries are not spread evenly. The author's estimate sees about 25 trips during the busiest week:
Feed peaks as the birds grow.
Bird lorries come together at catching, with up to about 28 lorry passes in a single night.
Manure leaves at clean-out.
Feed and bird-collection drive the rise in lorry visits per crop For the first four weeks lorry visits are at or below 1 visit per day. At week 5 they double, at week 6 they more than treble.

Data source: application Environment Statement/Transport Statement paragraphs 15.3.4 and 15.3.6
The Traffic Statement offers no assesment of no lane widths, passing-places, swept-path check of the turns, no bridge assessment and no road safety audit (the applicant notes no recorded accidents on Holewater Hill in the past ten years).
It concludes there is “unlikely to be any detrimental impact”, and no controls on routes or hours are proposed. The council’s pre-application advice accepted the site access, which covers the farm entrance only.
TRAFFIC CONCLUSION
The author believes the application understates the effect on the village. The proposal would nearly triple heavy lorry traffic on the lane past the school, the village hall and homes that front the road, yet it assesses none of the lane, the pinch points, the bridge, school traffic or night movements. Even the lorry figures are incomplete: staff, catching crews, contractors and construction traffic are left out, as is the farm’s existing beef and lamb traffic and what appears locally to be a new egg-laying operation. The application also offers no plan for when the route to the A399 is blocked. The only other ways out, via Yarde Down to North Molton and South Molton or across the moor to Simonsbath, are unsuitable for repeated HGV use, with narrow lanes, tight bends and few passing places too short for multiple vehicles. With detoured village traffic added, they could quickly become blocked. A blockage at the busiest point in the farm’s cycle, at catching or clean-out, would be especially disruptive: birds must leave when they reach weight, and the applicant’s only contingency is for bird collection to be “delayed or brought forward”. Only the council can impose routing, hours or passing-place conditions, so these need to be secured at planning stage.
Additionally, the application gives no consideration of the proposed development of about 14 homes beside the village hall. On the author’s count, about 36 vehicles currently join the lane directly from properties along it; two vehicles per new household would add around 28 more, an increase of nearly 80%. Because the housing has not yet been approved, the applicant is not strictly required to assess it; the EIA rules require cumulative effects to be considered with existing and approved projects. The council, however, decides on the actual conditions the lane would face, and national policy asks it to take account of cumulative effects on living conditions. It should therefore weigh the two proposals together.
What would actually be enforceable here?
Promise or prediction | Is this binding in any way? |
Mitigation described in the Environmental Statement | No, unless written into a permit or planning condition. No draft permit conditions have been submitted |
Management plans for odour, dust, noise and litter | Only if a permit condition requires them to be followed. Several are still to be prepared |
Avoiding clean-outs when the wind blows towards homes | No. Qualified by "if at all possible" |
An odour limit at homes | None proposed, and no current official benchmark to set one against |
Where litter goes | Disposal called "assumptions only". Once litter leaves the farm, the main duty is to record dates and amounts |
Lorry routes and hours | None proposed. The permit does not cover traffic. Only the council can impose controls |
Bird numbers | Not stated in the formal description of the development the council would decide |
Water monitoring | "No monitoring will be undertaken at the installation" |
Recurring themes among intensive broiler production facilities
Theme | What residents report | Relevance at Brayford |
Smell indoors and out | Unable to sit outside, open windows or dry washing | Exmoor View about 8 m (EA) and nearest homes 149 m (applicant), closer than Hollins Lane (460 m) and inside the 250 to 400 m distance Public Health England flagged at East Huntspill |
Timing | Worst in summer and when wind funnels it | West-facing gable fans, secondary easterly winds, valley setting (Article 4) |
Holiday and rural business | Lost bookings | Holiday lets near the site, including Exmoor View, 8 m from the boundary |
Complaints and response | Years of complaints; slow or limited action; sometimes determined as"compliant" | Odour limit and complaint procedure not yet proposed (Article 14) |
Outcomes | Changes in feed or bird numbers, stronger plans, or closure, usually after long campaigns | Planning is the stage when limits can be set in advance |
Flies | Swarms in homes for months; a council abatement notice (Fulmodeston); a permit prosecution (Milton Damerel) | The Milton Damerel prosecution was in Torridge, the neighbouring district; litter would be handled at clean-outs on a site whose nearest homes are 149 m from the boundary (Article 4) |
Night lorries | Catching lorries in the early hours; a neighbour moving bedrooms | Penhros is a similar size; about 40 of 66 lorry trips a crop fall in weeks 5 and 6 (Article 8) |
What recourse is there in the event of complaint
Route | What it can do | Its limits |
Complain to the Environment Agency | Investigate; require a revised plan; enforce, up to revoking the permit | The farm is compliant if it uses "appropriate measures", even if the smell continues. The usual outcome is a revised plan |
Statutory nuisance, through the council | An abatement notice for smell, dust or noise | For a permitted farm, the council needs the Secretary of State's consent to start proceedings (Environmental Protection Act 1990, s79(10)). The operator can defend itself by showing "best practicable means" (s80) |
A resident's own complaint to the magistrates (s82) | The same, brought by a resident | The same defence; the time, evidence and cost fall on the resident |
Private nuisance claim | Damages or an injunction | Civil court action: slow and expensive |
Judicial review | Challenges the lawfulness of the permission or permit | There is no public right of appeal against either decision. Judicial review tests the process, not the merits, and has strict time limits |
Objections: what counts, and what does not
Usually considered | Not usually considered |
Effects on living conditions: odour, noise, dust, light, disturbance | Loss of property value |
Highway safety and the suitability of the lane | Loss of a private view |
Pollution, and effects on health and the natural environment | Who the applicant is, or opinions about them |
Ancient woodland, priority habitats, protected sites and biodiversity net gain | General opposition to intensive farming |
Landscape, the setting of Exmoor National Park, and heritage settings | Matters controlled entirely by other laws, such as animal welfare standards |
Drainage, flood risk and groundwater | Business competition |
Cumulative effects with other development | |
Whether the Environmental Impact Assessment is complete and accurate | |
Local Plan policies and national planning policy |