By the Numbers
8 errors, 35 contradictions, 55 omissions and 15 shortfalls
Taken together, these figures matter for the people the application was meant to inform. Residents reading the public notice were told of a like-for-like replacement of four poultry houses, with no mention that bird numbers would rise 4.4 times, that the sheds would extend into an undeveloped field, or that lorry trips would nearly treble, so many may not have realised the application affected them, or may have judged it not worth a comment.
The organisations asked for advice were in a similar position. Environmental Health, Highways, South West Water and others responded on the applicant’s documents as submitted, and those documents contain more than 90 errors, omissions, contradictions and shortfalls against current standards. A “no objection” given on a withdrawn odour benchmark, an overstated ammonia baseline, a premise that traffic would be “not materially different”, or a drainage report that was never published can only be as sound as the information it was given.
This is not a criticism of the officers who responded. It means their "no objection" responses cannot yet be treated as a clearance, and that both the public and the consultees should have the chance to comment again once the application has been corrected and completed.
A Breakdown of Issues
Every figure here comes from the public report (revision 370). The sections follow the report's 15 sections in order. Source numbers [#] match the report's source list: [1] is the planning file and [2] is the EA permit file, the file source list is at the end.
Basis says where a number comes from.
Applicant means the application or permit documents.
Calculation means our arithmetic on the applicant's or standard figures.
Indicative means our own screening or terrain analysis, which is not a modelled result. External means a published official or third-party source.
Residents means measured locally.
Shows says what the number illustrates: Below standard, Contradiction, Error, Missing or Impact.
01 · Summary
These are the headline figures. Each is set out in more detail in its own section below.
Figure | What it shows | Shows | Basis | Source |
40,000 → 176,000 birds (4.4 times) | Free range replaced by housed birds, with 4.4 times as many | Impact | Applicant | [1] |
About 3.5 times more ammonia | On the government's factors. The applicant says about 2% less | Error | Calculation | [1][3] |
1.24 µg/m³ against a 1.0 limit | Ancient woodland already over its limit before the farm adds anything | Below standard | Applicant | [1] |
About 163 → 459–488 lorry trips a year | Nearly three times today, on the only road through Brayford | Contradiction | Calculation | [1] |
1,800–3,200 tonnes of litter a year | No tonnage, destination or assessment given | Missing | Calculation | [19][20] |
About 200 m to Exmoor National Park | The ES never mentions the park | Missing | Residents | [1] |
171 characters | The public description leaves out the bird numbers and the expansion | Missing | Applicant | [1] |
26 points across 6 consultee responses | Errors, omissions or inconsistencies those responses did not address | Missing | Calculation | [1] |
02 · The proposal
This section covers scale, the site and neighbours. The applicant's own documents disagree on bird numbers, crops a year and the distance to the nearest home.
Figure | What it shows | Shows | Basis | Source |
4 sheds, each about 103 m × 24 m | New housed broiler sheds | Impact | Applicant | [1] |
3,561 → 10,108 m² of shed floor (2.8 times) | A much larger footprint than the four houses it replaces | Impact | Applicant | [1] |
About 220,000 → about 1.2–1.3 million birds a year | 40,000 × 5.5 crops today; 176,000 × 7 to 7.45 crops proposed. The ES gives 1,232,000 | Impact | Calculation | [1] |
7 crops a year (ES) against 7.5 (odour, ammonia and dust reports) | The air models and the ES assume different numbers of crops | Contradiction | Applicant | [1] |
38 days (air reports) against about 39 days (ES) to slaughter | The age at removal differs between documents | Contradiction | Applicant | [1] |
7–10 days of clear-out and washing each crop | Odour and lorries are concentrated in these days | Impact | Applicant | [1] |
Eight 9 m silos, eight gas tanks, a 100,000-litre water tank, an 8.2 m storage building | Industrial plant covered only by "installation of plant" | Missing | Applicant | [1] |
85–90 m into an undeveloped field | The expansion is not stated in the description | Missing | Applicant | [1] |
171 characters | The public notice omits the 4.4-fold increase, the expansion and the plant | Missing | Applicant | [1] |
Site at about 200–210 m, homes downhill on three sides | Cold air and odour drain towards homes | Impact | Applicant | [1] |
Five distances to the nearest home: 149 m, about 180 m, about 190 m, about 260 m and "more than 500m" | The ES uses "more than 500m" to rate dust "low" | Contradiction | Applicant | [1][2] |
Exmoor View: 8 m from the permit boundary | Not in any odour, noise or dust assessment | Missing | External (EA) | [2] |
Braycross Cottages 150 m · Catkins 180–270 m | Nearest homes | Impact | Residents | [1] |
Village hall and pre-school 335 m · Brayford Academy grounds 370 m · Grade I church 450 m | Not in any assessment | Missing | Residents | [1] |
2005: refusal on smell and distance · 2012: deliveries limited to 07:00–18:00 | NDC has already judged odour and night working here a problem, at a fraction of this scale | Contradiction | Applicant (NDC decisions) | [1] |
03 · Ammonia, woodland and wildlife
On the government's factors, ammonia rises about 3.5 times. It would fall on woodland that is already over every limit.
Figure | What it shows | Shows | Basis | Source |
176,000 × 0.024 kg = about 4,224 kg a year proposed | The new sheds' ammonia | Impact | Calculation | [1][3] |
40,000 × 0.03 kg = 1,200 kg a year today | Today's farm on the government's free-range factor | Error | Calculation | [3] |
About 3.5 times (4,224 ÷ 1,200) | The real change: an increase, not a fall | Error | Calculation | [1][3] |
0.024 + 0.084 kg a bird = 4,320 kg a year | The applicant counts each free-range bird twice, indoors and outdoors all year | Error | Applicant | [1] |
About 2% less (4,224 against 4,320) | The applicant's claimed "improvement" | Error | Calculation | [1] |
3.6 times (4,320 ÷ 1,200) | How much the applicant overstates today's farm. The EA says to use the "lowest baseline impacts" | Below standard | Calculation | [1][3][4] |
Ancient woodland within 250 m (Barton Woods) | Confirmed by the EA; missed by the earlier screening | Missing | External (EA) | [2] |
Ammonia 1.24 against a 1.0 µg/m³ limit | The woodland is already over its limit | Below standard | Applicant | [1] |
Nitrogen 28.65 against a 10 kg/ha/yr limit | Already nearly three times its limit | Below standard | Applicant | [1] |
Acid 2.10 against the EA's 1.984 keq/ha/yr limit | Already over; the EA asked for acid modelling and none was done | Missing | Applicant | [1][2] |
77–81% of the limit (76.82% and 80.52%) | The new farm's own addition at the two nearest woodland points | Impact | Applicant | [1] |
About 2.0 µg/m³ (1.24 + 0.77) | Twice the woodland limit | Impact | Calculation | [1] |
North Exmoor SSSI: 0.21% → 0.31% | A rise, even with today's farm overstated | Contradiction | Applicant | [1] |
South Exmoor SSSI/SAC: 0.19% → 0.30% | A rise, even with today's farm overstated | Contradiction | Applicant | [1] |
JNCC thresholds 0.08 / 0.20 / 0.34 / 0.75% | Set for high, medium, low and very low development density. 0.30% is above the high and medium thresholds, and the report does not say which density applies | Missing | Applicant | [1] |
North Exmoor 3.6% (screening) against about 0.31% (detailed model) | More than tenfold apart, with no explanation | Contradiction | Applicant | [1] |
30–50 m below the sheds | Still-night cold air drains to the ancient woodland, but calms are left out of the ammonia model | Missing | Indicative | [1][30] |
89% of UK ammonia from agriculture · 16% cut from 2005 levels by 2030 | The national context for a 3.5-fold increase | Impact | External | [6][42] |
South Exmoor: "Unfavourable - Declining" (2013 assessment) | Habitat already recorded in poor condition | Impact | External | [43] |
04 · Odour
The odour result rests on a withdrawn pass mark and fixed assumptions. The still nights that matter most have not been assessed.
Figure | What it shows | Shows | Basis | Source |
5.57 odour units at Braycross Cottages today · 7.51 at the applicant's farmhouse | Odour harm already exists, above even the withdrawn pass mark | Impact | Applicant | [1] |
Pass mark of 3 odour units | Taken from EA guidance withdrawn in December 2025 | Below standard | External | [10] |
1.5 "slight adverse" · 3 "moderate adverse" | IAQM bands for a home. Braycross Cottages and High Bray stay in the adverse range | Below standard | External | [11] |
3 places where odour rises, including the Barns at Withygate | Odour gets worse at some places on the applicant's own figures | Impact | Applicant | [1] |
2002 study; the same rate for a 10,000-bird and a 44,000-bird house | Odour inside the sheds is not adjusted for stocking density | Error | Applicant | [1] |
3 release points per shed at a fixed 11.0 m/s in every hour | Exit speed is fixed, even at minimum ventilation | Missing | Applicant | [1] |
14 roof fans per shed; 25% assumed running at night | The noise report's night assumption, which the odour model does not test | Contradiction | Applicant | [1] |
Clean-out: 2 hours a house modelled, up to 24 hours allowed | The smelliest part of each crop could last up to 12 times longer than modelled | Contradiction | Applicant | [1][2] |
Houses 2.8 times today's size, but the same 2 hours | Clean-out time is not scaled | Error | Calculation | [1] |
23°C | Above this, the gable fans carry half the emissions, and the western ones face Brayford | Impact | Applicant | [1] |
Weather from a grid about 7 km wide | Not the site's own wind measurements | Missing | Applicant | [1] |
135 of 144 night readings at 1 m/s or less (94%) | The applicant's own station shows near-still nights | Impact | Applicant | [1] |
139–354 still, clear night hours a year (2022–25) | How often the conditions that matter occur | Impact | Indicative | [14] |
Worst 2% of hours = about 175 hours a year | How bad those hours are is never reported | Missing | Calculation | [1] |
About 27 m (Braycross) and about 70 m (River Bray valley) below the sheds | Cold-air routes west, through Brayford | Impact | Indicative | [30] |
30–50 m below the sheds | Cold-air route east, towards Hole Water and the ancient woodland | Impact | Indicative | [30] |
3 of the applicant's receptor points within 2 m of a valley floor | Odour carried downhill would collect where people live | Impact | Indicative | [30] |
About 20 to over 200 odour units in an hour | Screening, if odour leaves slowly and stays low | Impact | Indicative | Our working |
About 12–14 odour units | Screening at the model's fixed 11 m/s, from Lower Hall and Brayford outwards | Impact | Indicative | [30] |
05 · Night-time noise, catching and thinning
The noise report assesses the fans only. Catching, thinning and lorries at night are left out of a very quiet night background.
Figure | What it shows | Shows | Basis | Source |
25 dB night background | Nights here are very quiet | Impact | Applicant | [1] |
"No change" in transport, against lorry trips per crop rising 29.5 → 65.5 | The premise for leaving out lorries and catching | Contradiction | Applicant | [1] |
"Bird catching frequently occurring during night time" | The applicant's EA noise assessment, with reversing alarms | Contradiction | Applicant | [2] |
0 peak-noise assessments | The noise most likely to wake people is unmeasured | Missing | Applicant | [1] |
Wrawby Farm: catching 62 dB, peaks 79 dB at 20 m, homes 510–585 m away | The same consultant assessed night catching elsewhere | Contradiction | External | [15] |
Higher Hall: homes from 150 m away, catching not assessed | Closer homes, less assessment | Missing | Residents | [1] |
30 kg/m² stated · legal limit 33 kg/m², or 39 with extra conditions | The stated density sits below the legal maximum | Missing | Applicant / External | [1][16] |
30 kg/m² passed around day 29–30 · 39 kg/m² around day 35 | On Ross 308 growth, allowing 3% losses | Missing | Calculation | [17] |
About 54,000 birds (nearly a third) | Must be thinned to hold 30 kg/m²: a second catching night every crop | Missing | Calculation | [1][17] |
Penhros Farm: "just under a third" thinned at just over 4 weeks | Thinning is normal practice for a comparable unit | Impact | External | [37] |
Breed and slaughter weight: not stated | So the operation proposed cannot be checked | Missing | Applicant | [1] |
06 · Lorries through Brayford
On the applicant's own figures, lorry trips nearly treble. Professional guidance calls for assessment at a 30% rise.
Figure | What it shows | Shows | Basis | Source |
29.5 → 65.5 trips a crop (+122%) | The Transport Statement's own totals | Contradiction | Applicant | [1] |
About 163 → 459–488 trips a year | 29.5 × about 5.5 crops (a 66-day cycle) today; 65.5 × 7 to 7.45 crops proposed | Contradiction | Calculation | [1] |
918–976 movements a year | Each trip is a journey in and out | Impact | Calculation | [1] |
Feed 7→26 · birds 6→22 · chicks 1→4 · gas 1→3 a crop | Where the increase comes from | Impact | Applicant | [1] |
About +180–200% a year, against the IEMA 30% trigger | Six times the level at which assessment is expected | Below standard | Calculation / External | [1][18] |
"Not considered to be materially different than the existing" | The premise Highways relied on | Contradiction | Applicant | [1] |
Gas: "2 per year" (Transport Statement Review) against "2 per cycle" (ES) | The documents disagree on the increase | Contradiction | Applicant | [1] |
31 of the 65.5 trips (47%) | Bunched at the end of each crop and the clear-out | Impact | Calculation | [1] |
1 dirty-water lorry a crop, against 170,000–190,000 litres of wash water | Tanker trips are likely undercounted | Contradiction | Calculation | [1][49] |
3 injury collisions (Dec 2022 – Aug 2025), 2 serious, 6 people hurt, 2 of them children | At the A399 junction on the construction route. No lorry was involved | Missing | External | [46] |
0 collision analysis | The Transport Statement has no author, date, route or assessment | Missing | Applicant | [1] |
About 3.5 m wall to kerb at the Old Post Office, no pavement | A 2.55 m lorry leaves less than 50 cm each side | Impact | Residents | [1] |
46 weeks of construction, all through Brayford | No vehicle numbers given | Missing | Applicant | [1] |
07 · Manure: where does it go?
No tonnage or destination is given. Scaled from two comparable units, the farm would produce roughly 1,800–3,200 tonnes of used litter a year.
Figure | What it shows | Shows | Basis | Source |
0 tonnes stated | The application gives no litter tonnage | Missing | Applicant | [1] |
11 t (Old Rush) and 18 t (Caffyn) per 1,000 bird places a year | The two comparators used | Impact | External | [19][20] |
About 1,800–3,200 t a year | 176,000 places scaled from those comparators | Missing | Calculation | [19][20] |
About 33–58 t of nitrogen a year | At about 18 kg N a tonne (the Caffyn ratio) | Impact | Calculation | [19] |
4 or more destinations, none named | AD plant, third parties, neighbouring farms, operator land, field heaps | Contradiction | Applicant | [1][2] |
"Operator controlled land" against the permit form's "No" | The documents disagree on whether it is spread by the operator | Contradiction | Applicant | [1][2] |
11 tractor-trailers → 8 lorries a crop | Manure trips fall while the birds rise 4.4 times | Contradiction | Applicant | [1] |
31–57 t a lorry needed, against a typical 27–30 t | The lorry figures fit only the bottom of the tonnage range | Contradiction | Calculation | [1][20] |
Squire 2019 · Finch 2024 · Caffyn 2025 (200,000 birds) | The courts quashed permissions that left manure unassessed | Below standard | External | [19][21][22] |
Since 2006 | NDC has controlled manure spreading here by condition | Contradiction | Applicant (NDC decisions) | [1] |
08 · Water, drainage and groundwater
About 1.7 hectares of run-off would soak into the ground above a highly vulnerable aquifer. The drainage report is missing and no water demand is stated.
Figure | What it shows | Shows | Basis | Source |
About 1.7 ha of roofs and yards | The area draining to infiltration | Impact | Applicant | [1] |
"Appendix 1" drainage strategy: not published | The design cannot be checked | Missing | Applicant | [1] |
0.837 m/h used, against 0.296 m/h at the pit closer to the basin | The slower pit drains 2.8 times more slowly | Contradiction | Applicant | [1] |
About 75 m | Neither test pit is this close to the basin or the soakaway | Below standard | Residents (from the applicant's drawing) | [1] |
3 test pits mentioned, 2 shown | One pit is missing from the drawings | Missing | Applicant | [1] |
1 m clearance above groundwater; monitoring ideally for a year | Devon's guidance. None is reported | Below standard | External | [45] |
Dirty-water tanks: 62,000 or 63,000 litres, underground or above ground | The documents disagree | Contradiction | Applicant | [1][2] |
170,000–190,000 litres of wash water a clean-out | Nearly three times what the tanks hold | Missing | Calculation | [49] |
3 different destinations for clean water | Basin, soakaways and ditch, or tank for reuse | Contradiction | Applicant | [1][2] |
Secondary A aquifer, high vulnerability | Sensitive groundwater under the site | Impact | Applicant (EA) | [2] |
"No monitoring will be undertaken" | Contamination would go undetected | Missing | Applicant | [2] |
About 1.1–1.2 million litres of drinking water a crop (22–24 m³ a day) | No document states the water demand or the source | Missing | Calculation | [17][24] |
+6–7% for each degree above 21°C | Water use rises in hot weather | Impact | External | [48] |
20 m³ a day | Above this, abstraction is likely to need a licence | Below standard | External | [25] |
13 disinfectants and biocides, 480 litres of formalin a year, 3 antibiotics | No assessment for the aquifer, springs or land | Missing | Applicant | [2] |
Brayford sewage works: 172 spills, 3,763 hours (2025); 205 spills, 4,512 hours (2024) | 5th longest of South West Water's 334 works; the same water body | Impact | External | [44] |
09 · Exmoor, landscape, dark skies and tourism
The National Park boundary is about 200 m away, and the ES never mentions it. There is no landscape and visual impact assessment (LVIA).
Figure | What it shows | Shows | Basis | Source |
About 200 m to the park boundary (Holewater Hill) | Mentioned 0 times in the ES | Missing | Residents | [1] |
0 viewpoints, 0 LVIA | "Moderate adverse" visual effect asserted, not assessed | Missing | Applicant | [1] |
Sheds over 100 m long, eight 9 m silos, an 8.2 m storage building | The scale in the view | Impact | Applicant | [1] |
"Cannot be seen" from any public road or footpath, against sheds visible from Whitefield Lane | The application form is contradicted by the National Park Authority | Contradiction | Applicant / ENPA | [1] |
About 66,000 tonnes of excavated soil | No cut-and-fill calculation shows it balances on site (Devon CPRE) | Missing | Applicant | [1] |
One 30 W floodlight against security lights of up to 150 W | The ES gives two lighting descriptions, and never mentions the Dark Sky Reserve | Contradiction | Applicant | [1] |
7 listed buildings within 1 km, including the Grade I church | No heritage statement | Missing | Applicant | [1] |
"No historic evidence" against a possible prehistoric enclosure, flints and Romano-British iron-working | Contradicted by DCC's Historic Environment Team | Contradiction | Applicant / DCC | [1] |
2 full-time jobs claimed | Set against the visitor economy | Impact | Applicant | [1] |
Exmoor 2024: 1.6 million visits, £242 million, 2,377 FTE jobs | Tourism is mentioned 0 times in the ES | Missing | External | [27] |
Wedding venue opened in 2025, with outdoor ceremonies | Visitors are not considered in any assessment | Missing | External | [28] |
10 · Gaps in the Environmental Statement
The unit is over twice the EIA threshold, but parts of the assessment the law requires are missing, and the application contradicts itself.
Figure | What it shows | Shows | Basis | Source |
85,000 broilers | The EIA threshold. 176,000 is more than twice it | Below standard | External | [29] |
0 non-technical summaries | Required by the EIA Regulations | Missing | Applicant | [1][29] |
0 alternatives described | The "Alternative Sites" chapter describes none | Missing | Applicant | [1] |
0 cumulative assessments | No other farms, no Brayford Quarry | Missing | Applicant | [1] |
176,000 · 173,926 · 172,728 birds | Three bird numbers, so it is unclear what would be permitted | Contradiction | Applicant | [1][2] |
5 chimney heights (5.5–6.95 m), against 6.2 m in the air models | The height built decides where odour and ammonia land | Contradiction | Applicant | [1] |
"Heating/Pyrolysis Building" against heating by gas | Possible combustion emissions are not assessed | Contradiction | Applicant | [1] |
"No" to trees or hedges, watercourses, protected species, important habitats and visibility | Each contradicted by the applicant's own reports | Contradiction | Applicant | [1] |
100 m | The EA requires a dust and bioaerosol plan where people live within this distance | Below standard | External | [4] |
Exmoor View: 8 m, described as a "staff dwelling" | Its planning permission limits it to holiday use (NDC 35127, condition 6) | Error | Applicant | [1] |
PM10 limit "may be exceeded" near the gable fans | Admitted in the ES | Impact | Applicant | [1] |
0 bioaerosol assessments supplied | The dust plan relies on one that is not on file | Missing | Applicant | [2] |
11 · Health
On the EA's standard factor, dust rises more than fourfold. The school, the pre-school and the village hall are in no assessment.
Figure | What it shows | Shows | Basis | Source |
About 4 → about 17.6 tonnes of dust a year | 0.1 kg a bird a year (EA factor) × 40,000 and × 176,000 | Impact | Calculation | [1] |
Brayford Academy grounds about 370 m · village hall and pre-school about 335 m | Named in none of the odour, dust or noise assessments | Missing | Residents | [1][2] |
0 bioaerosol assessments | None supplied for Higher Hall | Missing | Applicant | [2] |
2018 systematic review | Mixed results near intensive farms; more reported asthma among children nearby, from a small number of studies | Impact | External | [31] |
2021 review of 30 studies (13 livestock) | More headaches (odds ratio 1.15) and coughs (1.27) near industrial odour sources; mostly self-reported | Impact | External | [47] |
"Negligible" disease risk to nearby homes | Airborne routes are not considered | Missing | Applicant | [1] |
25 dB night background | Night catching and lorries fall when people sleep | Impact | Applicant | [1] |
12 · Brayford Quarry and combined effects
A quarry with an asphalt plant about 1 km away is not mentioned anywhere in the application.
Figure | What it shows | Shows | Basis | Source |
About 1 km from the nearest shed, and about 1 km from the school and village hall | Brayford Quarry is mentioned 0 times in the application | Missing | Residents | [1] |
11.29 µg/m³ PM10 | The highest background dust in the area, in the 1 km square that contains the quarry | Impact | Applicant | [1] |
Up to 50 nights a year, until the end of 2029 | The quarry's application (May 2026) to run the asphalt plant at night | Impact | External | [33] |
5 km and 10 km | No other poultry or livestock units within these distances were considered for in-combination effects | Missing | Applicant | [1][9] |
0 cumulative assessments | Required by the EIA Regulations | Below standard | Applicant | [1][29] |
13 · Emergencies
The permit documents rate every hazard "Not significant", but give no plan, or only a partial one, for events of this size.
Figure | What it shows | Shows | Basis | Source |
About 440 tonnes of live birds at the end of a crop | About 171,000 birds × about 2.6 kg. No holding, route or timetable for a cull | Missing | Calculation | [2][17] |
About 5,300 deaths in a normal crop (3%) | Everyday losses | Impact | Calculation | [2] |
4 m × 4 m dead-bird store | Collection given as once every 2 crops, "twice weekly" and "regularly" | Contradiction | Applicant | [1][2] |
Generator on site, against one "sourced within 4 hrs" | The Emergency Plan and the Odour Management Plan disagree | Contradiction | Applicant | [2] |
0 generators on the drawings | Nothing shows one could run the fans of all 4 houses | Missing | Applicant | [1] |
0 assessments of power failure | Not in the Accident Assessment | Missing | Applicant | [2] |
1 hand-operated valve | One missed turn sends wash water to the basin above the aquifer | Impact | Applicant | [1] |
14 · After approval: who protects residents?
Once the farm is running, protection rests on the operator's weekly self-check and infrequent EA inspections.
Figure | What it shows | Shows | Basis | Source |
1 boundary "sniff test" a week, by the operator's own staff | The only routine check proposed | Missing | Applicant | [2] |
Up to 14 days' notice of an EA inspection | Inspections are announced in advance | Impact | External | [34] |
EA inspection 1 year in 3 for assurance-scheme farms | A certification body inspects in the other 2 years | Impact | External | [34] |
More than 3,000 breaches in 5 years | At intensive livestock farms in England; many got "advice and guidance" rather than sanctions | Impact | External | [35] |
Hollins Lane: 235,000 birds, more than 80 complaints, about 460 m away | The EA said the operations complied with the permit | Impact | External | [36] |
Penhros Farm: 4 sheds of 42,000 birds, neighbour about 235 m away | "Horrible sweet sickly smell", "24/7" | Impact | External | [37] |
Footbridge Farm: 210,000 places | Quashed, then the appeal was dismissed | Impact | External | [12][21] |
Banham Poultry: £300,000 fine (2022) after complaints from 2019 to 2021 | Even successful enforcement takes years | Impact | External | [38] |
15 · The official responses
The six responses that did not object, or reached no conclusion, leave 26 points unaddressed (22 in five "no objection" responses, 4 in Natural England's).
Figure | What it shows | Shows | Basis | Source |
Environmental Health (18 Sep 2026): 7 points unaddressed | Relied on a withdrawn pass mark and fixed fan speeds | Missing | Calculation | [1] |
Environment Agency (18 Sep 2026): 2 points | The "revised" ammonia report has the same text as the May version | Missing | Calculation | [1][2] |
Natural England (1 Oct 2026): 4 points | Asked for an assessment that has not been done | Missing | Calculation | [1] |
DCC Highways (15 Oct 2026): 4 points | Relied on "not materially different" against +122% a crop | Contradiction | Calculation | [1] |
"2022-2031" against 2011–2031 | Highways cites the wrong Local Plan period | Error | Applicant / External | [1][26] |
30% trigger against about 180–200% | Highways did not apply the IEMA guidance | Below standard | Calculation / External | [18] |
South West Water (18 Sep 2026): 4 points | No view on rates, groundwater or water quality; the second pit is 2.8 times slower | Missing | Calculation | [1] |
NDC Sustainability (23 Sep 2026): 5 points | Ammonia on the woodland is not in the metric | Missing | Calculation | [1] |
1 survey visit, in February | Outside the best survey season | Below standard | Applicant | [1] |
About 130 m of species-rich hedgerow lost | A priority habitat | Impact | Applicant | [1] |
Waste audit: 68,320 t in all, 66,000 t of soil reused, 0 t of manure | The one consultee on waste was not asked about the largest waste stream | Missing | Applicant | [1] |
Parish Council asks for no avoidable lorries 19:00–07:00 | The local view on night lorries | Impact | Applicant (public file) | [1] |
Lead Local Flood Authority: 0 responses on file | Flood risk not considered by the responsible body | Missing | Applicant (public file) | [1] |
Sources These numbers match the full report's source list. Numbers not cited on this page are skipped.
[1] North Devon Council, planning application 82141: the Environmental Statement (Aug 2026), Design and Access Statement, Odour, Ammonia and Dust Reports, Noise Impact Assessment, Transport Statement, Waste Audit, drawings 200_01–200_18, consultee responses and public comments. Earlier decisions on the farm (35127, 41689, 41690, 46946, 46951) are on the same portal.
[2] Environment Agency, permit consultation EPR/FP3722MA/A001: application form, Odour and Noise Management Plans, noise and odour risk assessments, Site Condition Report, Dust and Bioaerosol Management Plan, Site Closure Plan, and the EA's request for information (12 Aug 2026).
[3] GOV.UK, Ammonia emission factors for pig and poultry (Dec 2024).
[4] GOV.UK, Intensive farming risk assessment for your environmental permit (May 2026).
[6] Defra, Emissions of air pollutants in the UK: ammonia (Feb 2026).
[9] Natural England, Air pollution and development: advice for local authorities (Dec 2025).
[10] Environment Agency, Odour management: comply with your environmental permit (Dec 2025), section 5.
[11] Institute of Air Quality Management, Guidance on the assessment of odour for planning, version 1.1 (July 2018), Table 7 ("moderately offensive" odours). An updated draft went out for consultation in March 2026.
[12] Footbridge Farm appeal, APP/L3245/W/21/3289216 (dismissed 5 May 2023), paras 8–13.
[14] Open-Meteo historical weather (ERA5 reanalysis): night hours with wind of 2 metres a second or less and cloud cover of 40% or less, 2022–25, at the applicant's weather point. Indicative.
[15] Matrix Acoustics, Wrawby Farm, Brigg, noise impact assessment M2531/R01 (22 Oct 2025). Copy available on request.
[16] Welfare of Farmed Animals (England) Regulations 2007, Schedule 5A, and Schedule 1 (back-up ventilation and alarm).
[17] Aviagen, Ross 308 broiler performance objectives (2022).
[18] Institute of Environmental Management and Assessment, Guidelines for the Environmental Assessment of Traffic and Movement (2023), Rule 1, as quoted in a published Environmental Statement.
[19] R (Caffyn) v Shropshire Council [2025] EWHC 1497 (Admin), paras 8, 32 and 67–68.
[20] Old Rush Farm Environmental Statement (Harrison Pick for Ruston Eggs, Sept 2025), para 10.2 and Table 3.1.
[21] R (Squire) v Shropshire Council [2019] EWCA Civ 888, paras 39–80.
[22] R (Finch) v Surrey County Council [2024] UKSC 20, paras 77 and 108.
[24] Aviagen, Ross broiler handbook: water-to-feed ratio of 1.6–1.8 to 1.
[25] GOV.UK, Check if you need a licence to abstract water.
[26] North Devon and Torridge Local Plan 2011–2031 (2018), policies DM01, DM02, DM08 and DM08A; paragraph 5.30.
[27] Exmoor National Park, STEAM tourism figures 2024.
[28] The Barns at Withygate, venue listing.
[29] Town and Country Planning (Environmental Impact Assessment) Regulations 2017, Schedule 4; regulations 18, 25 and 26.
[30] Environment Agency, LiDAR Composite Digital Terrain Model (2 m), analysed by local residents for routes of steepest descent from the sheds. Indicative.
[31] Douglas and others, A systematic review of the public health risks of bioaerosols from intensive farming, International Journal of Hygiene and Environmental Health 221 (2018).
[33] Devon County Council planning register, application DCC/4462/2026 (Brayford Quarry, night working of the asphalt plant).
[34] GOV.UK, Intensive pig and poultry farm inspection.
[35] Bureau of Investigative Journalism, Fields of filth (29 Apr 2024).
[36] Shropshire Star, Dozens of complaints over chicken farm smell (23 Apr 2021).
[37] Bureau of Investigative Journalism, megafarms and their neighbours (21 Jul 2017), and Inside a UK megafarm (18 Jul 2017), which spell the farm "Penhros".
[38] Food Manufacture, Chicken slaughterhouse fined £300,000 for failing to stop odour pollution (3 Oct 2022).
[42] National Emission Ceilings Regulations 2018: ammonia reduction of 16% on 2005 levels from 2030.
[43] Natural England, Designated Sites View: condition of features, South Exmoor SSSI.
[44] MCBA, Brayford storm overflow, from Environment Agency event duration monitoring annual returns (EA ID SBB00148), 2024–2025: 205 spills and 4,512 hours in 2024; 172 spills and 3,763 hours in 2025.
[45] Devon County Council, SuDS guidance: groundwater monitoring for infiltration schemes (1 m clearance above the maximum groundwater level; ideally a year of readings, or November to May if time is short).
[46] Department for Transport, Road safety open data: police-reported injury collisions 2021–2025, filtered by local residents to the Brayford/A399 junction.
[47] Guadalupe-Fernandez V. et al., Industrial odour pollution and human health: a systematic review and meta-analysis, Environmental Health 20:108 (2021): pooled odds ratios for headache 1.15 and cough 1.27 among exposed residents.
[48] Aviagen, Water Quality (AA Update): water intake "will increase by 6-7% for each degree above 21°C".
[49] Luyckx K. et al., On-farm comparisons of different cleaning protocols in broiler houses, Poultry Science 94 (2015): about 16–18 litres per m² for pressure-washing plus about 1 litre per m² for soaking, applied here to the 10,108 m² of proposed sheds.