Response: Brayford Parish Council
29/0922026
What It States
Scale Increase: The development drastically expands the operation from 40,000 to 176,000 birds.
Traffic & Road Safety: The local road network consists of narrow, single-track rural lanes prone to wear. Heavy Goods Vehicles (HGVs) will increase in frequency, size, and weight, passing the local school and Village Hall entrance (used as a school car park) and endangering children, parents, and pedestrians.
Noise Levels: Increased traffic and HGV movements will disrupt properties close to the transport routes.
Odour Issues: The existing operation already produces an unpleasant odour affecting nearby and distant residents depending on the weather. The application lacks clarity on how the massive increase in manure and odour will be managed.
Agricultural Context: The Council acknowledges the importance of the agricultural community and the economic challenges farming businesses face in remaining viable.
What It Asks For
Clarification: Further details on manure management, storage, removal, and odour control before a final decision is made.
Traffic Restrictions: A ban on avoidable night-time HGV movements (such as feed deliveries and waste removal) between 7:00 pm and 7:00 am.
Planning Conditions: Legally binding safeguards and conditions to mitigate the impacts of traffic, noise, and odour.
Comprehensive Review: Full consideration of whether the massive scale of the development is appropriate for this specific location.
Other
Lighting Controls: External lighting must be tightly restricted to prevent light spill into the surrounding countryside, especially due to its proximity to the Exmoor Dark Skies area.
Visual Screening: The site requires sufficient landscaping and screening to hide the increased scale of the buildings from the surrounding rural area.
Comment The Parish Council considered the above application and wishes to highlight a number of concerns with significant increase in the scale of the proposed poultry operation and the potential impact this could have on the local community, surrounding properties and the rural road network. In particular, the Council seeks further clarification and appropriate safeguards in relation to increased traffic, noise and odour arising from the proposed development. The Parish Council recognises the important role of the agricultural community and the challenges faced by farming businesses in operating and developing viable enterprises. However, given the significant increase proposed in the scale of this operation, the Council considers that full consideration should be given to whether the size and scale of the development is appropriate in this particular location, taking into account the proximity of neighbouring properties and the substantial increase in large vehicle movements and associated activity that the development would generate The existing poultry buildings accommodate nearly 40,000 birds, while the proposed development would accommodate up to 176,000 birds. The local road network consists largely of narrow rural and single-track lanes, which are already subject to regular wear and maintenance issues. The increased frequency, size and weight of HGVs using these roads is a significant consideration, both in terms of the condition of the highway and the safety and amenity of residents and other road users. The Parish Council would also like to draw attention to the fact that the increased traffic will pass by the local school and the Village Hall entrance, which is also used by the school as a car park. This raises additional considerations regarding the safety of children, parents, and all other pedestrians, particularly at busy times when the school is being accessed. Additionally there is concern for the resulting increase in noise levels, particularly from HGV movements, and the impact this may have on properties close to the routes used. It is understood that bird movements take place at night for welfare reasons; however, should the application be approved, we would request that avoidable HGV movements, particularly feed deliveries and manure/waste removal be restricted between the nightime hours 7.00pm and 7.00am. The scale of the proposed increase means that unrestricted night-time lorry movements could be particularly disruptive to nearby properties. The increase in odour is also of great concern. Properties in close proximity to the existing operation are already impacted by the distinct and unpleasant odour, and there are also occasions when this affects a wider area and is noticeable to residents who live much further away to the site, depending on the prevailing weather conditions. The significant increase in the number of birds therefore makes the potential impact this would have on the local community an important consideration. The application does not, in the Parish Council's view, provide sufficient clarity as to how the increased volume of manure will be managed and removed, or how the potential increase in odour will be controlled. The Council therefore seeks further clarification prior to a decision being concluded regarding manure management, storage, removal and odour control, with suitable conditions imposed where necessary. The Parish Council also wishes to highlight the importance of appropriate lighting controls, given the site's rural location and proximity to the Exmoor Dark Skies area. External lighting should be carefully controlled to minimise light spill into the surrounding countryside and neighbouring properties. Sufficient screening and landscaping should also be provided to ensure that the increased scale of the development is adequately screened from the surrounding area. The Parish Council requests that these matters are fully considered and clearly understood before the application is determined, particularly the substantial increase in vehicle movements and the potential impact on the narrow rural road network, highway safety, the school and Village Hall entrance, noise levels, odour, lighting and the amenity of nearby properties. Where appropriate, suitable planning conditions should be imposed to mitigate any potential impacts. The Parish Council would ask that these matters are clarified and any necessary conditions identified before it reaches its decision on the application.