Full Report | Why the 176,000-bird broiler factory at Brayford should be refused
Updated: 3 days ago
Planning application 82141 · Environmental permit EPR/FP3722MA/A001 Report revision 421 · 18th November 2026
Index • Click to Jump
01 · Summary
North Devon Council (NDC) should refuse planning application 82141. The applicant's own documents do not show that a 176,000-bird broiler unit can operate at Higher Hall Farm without harm to neighbours, ancient woodland, Exmoor and the village of Brayford [1].
The proposal would replace a free-range farm of about 40,000 birds with four large housed sheds holding 4.4 times as many. The applicant presents this as an environmental improvement. Checked against government guidance and the applicant's other documents, that claim does not hold:
The description does not say what is proposed. "Demolition of x4 broiler units & erection of x4 new broiler units" omits the 4.4-fold increase in birds, the move into a new field and the industrial plant, so the public notice did not fairly tell people what they were being asked to comment on.
Ammonia would rise about 3.5 times, not fall. The calculation of today's farm uses emission factors far above the government's standard figure. An independent air-quality expert has since confirmed the error and, with his own modelling, found ammonia rising by 31–107% at the three protected points he examined [1]. The nearest ancient woodland is already over its safe limit, so the claimed improvement is in fact a 3.5-fold increase beside woodland that can take no more.
The odour prediction rests on assumptions, not measurement. It is judged against a benchmark withdrawn in December 2025, and the playground and village hall were never assessed, so the prediction NDC's officers accepted cannot be relied on.
Night-time activity is left out. The noise report assumes "no change" in transport, while the applicant's own figures show lorry trips nearly trebling and bird catching often taking place at night, so the noise most likely to wake people is missing from the assessment.
Lorries would roughly treble, from about 163 to 459–488 a year, on the only road through Brayford and past Brayford Academy, so the highway view that the traffic is "not considered to be materially different than the existing" rests on a false premise.
No one says where the manure goes. Roughly 1,800 to 3,200 tonnes of used litter a year would leave the site with no tonnage, no named destination and no assessment. The courts have ruled that approach unlawful, so a permission granted on this assessment would be open to challenge.
Drainage, water supply, landscape and Exmoor National Park are not properly assessed. The flood risk and drainage report has not been published, the Lead Local Flood Authority objects to the drainage scheme, and the Environmental Statement (ES) never mentions the National Park, whose boundary is about 200 m away, so the risks to water supplies and to Exmoor's setting are unknown.
Health, Brayford Quarry and emergencies are left out. There is no assessment of bioaerosols, of combined effects with the quarry's dust and planned night working, or of a disease outbreak involving up to 176,000 birds, so the effects that would fall on the village together are never weighed.
The "no objection" responses rest on the same gaps. Environmental Health, Highways and others relied on figures this report shows to be wrong or incomplete, and Natural England asked for an assessment that has not been done, so none of those responses can amount to a clearance.
These are not disagreements about judgement. They are gaps and inconsistencies in the evidence, which NDC must resolve before it can lawfully grant permission.
02 · The proposal
The applicant seeks to demolish four free-range poultry houses and build four new broiler sheds, each about 103 m long and 24 m wide, for 176,000 birds [1]. A separate environmental permit is sought from the Environment Agency (EA) [2].
Today | Proposed | |
Birds on site | about 40,000, free range | 176,000, housed |
Shed floor area | 3,561 m² | 10,108 m² (2.8 times) |
Crops a year | about 5.5 | about 7 |
Birds a year | about 220,000 | about 1.2 to 1.3 million |
Other structures | storage building (8.2 m high), eight 9 m feed silos, eight gas tanks, a 100,000-litre water tank, two dirty-water tanks, an infiltration basin |
A crop is one batch of birds: placed as day-old chicks, removed for slaughter at about 38–39 days, followed by 7–10 working days of clear-out and washing [1].
What the description does not say. The public notice describes the scheme in 171 characters: "Demolition of x4 broiler units & erection of x4 new broiler units with further associated buildings, solar array, installation of plant & creation of an infiltration basin" [1]. The application form uses similar words [1]. Neither tells a reader what is actually proposed:
The intensification is not stated. "x4 for x4" reads as a like-for-like replacement. It does not say that 40,000 free-range birds would become 176,000 housed birds, 4.4 times as many, so a reader cannot tell from the notice that the farm's output, traffic, odour and ammonia would multiply.
The expansion is not stated. The new sheds are 2.8 times the floor area of the old ones and extend 85–90 m into an undeveloped field [1], so neighbours on that side have no warning that buildings are coming towards them.
The industrial plant is not named. "Further associated buildings" and "installation of plant" cover eight 9 m silos, eight gas tanks, a 100,000-litre water tank, dirty-water tanks, a carcass store, an 8.2 m storage building and the drainage works [1], so the scale of what would be built cannot be judged from the notice.
Planning publicity exists so that people affected can understand a proposal and comment on it [41]. A description that leaves out the scale, the footprint and the nature of the development weakens that. NDC is unlikely to refuse on wording alone, but it should ensure the description states the bird numbers and the expansion before deciding, and re-publicise if necessary, so that its decision is not open to challenge on the ground that the public was not fairly told what was proposed.
The site. The farm sits on a col at about 200–210 m, between deeply cut river valleys, with homes downhill on three sides [1]. The western sheds extend about 85–90 m into an undeveloped field, and the site sections show the ground built up by several metres at the northern end [1].
Neighbours. The applicant's own documents give five different distances to the nearest home, from 149 m to "more than 500m" [1][2]. The Environmental Statement uses the "more than 500m" figure to rate dust as "low" [1], so that rating rests on the one distance every other document contradicts. The places closest to the sheds are:
Place | Approximate distance | Included in the odour, noise or dust assessments? |
Exmoor View, a holiday let shown on the applicant's location plan | 8 m from the permit boundary | No |
Braycross Cottages (three homes) | 150 m | Yes |
Catkins | 180–270 m | Yes |
Brayford village hall and pre-school | 335 m | Odour and dust only |
Brayford Academy grounds | 370 m | No |
Grade I Church of All Saints, High Bray | 450 m | No |
Distances were measured by residents on Google Earth from the application's red-line boundary to the boundary of each property, except Exmoor View, which the EA measured to the permit boundary [2].
NDC’s own decisions at this farm. The farm has grown in stages. Aerial imagery shows open fields here in 2001 [50]. In December 2005 NDC refused two applications, each for a single free-range poultry house with two feed silos, because each “would introduce an unacceptable impact on the amenities of the occupiers of neighbouring dwellings by virtue of the smell and distance from the applicant site” (41083, 41084) [1]. In June 2006 it approved two houses on amended plans (41689, 41690), and in September 2008 two more (46946, 46951), giving the four houses seen from the air by 2010 [1][50]. In December 2012 it approved extensions to the houses (54865, 54873, 54874), limiting deliveries of feed and chickens to 07:00–18:00, “limiting night time operations to the collecting of chickens”, and barring external lighting on the extensions without consent [1]. Application 82141 would replace those extended houses with sheds of 2.8 times the floor area, holding 4.4 times as many birds. So NDC has already judged odour and night working here a problem, at a fraction of this scale.
03 · Ammonia, woodland and wildlife
On the government's own emission factors, the new farm would give off about 3.5 times as much ammonia as the farm does today. The applicant's figures present it as an improvement, giving off about 2% less. This is incorrect.
Why ammonia matters. Agriculture produces 89% of the UK's ammonia, mostly from manure [6]. Ammonia settles on land as nitrogen, causing significant long-term harm to sensitive habitats [6]: it feeds coarse plants that smother mosses, lichens and woodland flowers, and it acidifies soil. In the air it reacts with other pollutants to form fine particles, which raise major health concerns [6]. Breathing ammonia, even at low levels, can irritate the eyes, nose and throat, and levels are higher where there is a lot of animal waste [5].
The UK is legally committed to cutting its ammonia emissions by 16% from 2005 levels by 2030 [42]. A 3.5-fold increase at one site runs against that national commitment.
How the figures differ. The applicant's Ammonia Report counts each of today's free-range birds twice: once as if indoors all year (0.024 kg a bird) and again as if outdoors all year (0.084 kg) [1]. The government's standard figure for a free-range broiler combines the two at 0.03 kg a bird [3]. The EA tells applicants to use the factors that give "the lowest baseline impacts" when comparing a farm before and after [4]. The applicant did the opposite, which puts today’s farm at 4,320 kg a year instead of about 1,200 kg, and makes the new farm look like an improvement.
Independently confirmed. On 16 November an independent review by Dr Michael Bull was placed on the file for Communities Against Factory Farming [1]. Dr Bull is a chartered engineer who chaired the Institute of Air Quality Management (IAQM) working group that wrote its odour guidance for planning. He finds the same error: the existing farm’s ammonia is overstated “by a factor of approximately 3.6”. With the emissions correctly allocated, his own modelling shows the proposal raising annual average ammonia at all three protected points he examined: by 31% at North Exmoor, 74% at the nearest ancient woodland point and 107% at South Exmoor. Like the applicant’s own comparison run, this was modelled without terrain or calms [1]. He recommends that NDC obtain a revised ammonia assessment before deciding, so the claimed improvement no longer rests on residents’ arithmetic: an independent expert has shown it is wrong.
Ancient woodland. The EA has confirmed ancient woodland (Barton Woods) within 250 m of the site [2]. The woods are already over every safe limit before the farm adds anything [1]:
ammonia in the air: 1.24 against a limit of 1.0 microgrammes per cubic metre (µg/m³);
nitrogen falling on the woods: 28.65 against a limit of 10 kilogrammes per hectare a year;
acid falling on the woods: 2.10 against the EA's limit of 1.984 kiloequivalents per hectare a year, which the applicant never modelled although the EA asked for it [2], so harm to the woodland's soils is unknown.
The new farm alone would add 77–81% of the ammonia limit at the two nearest woodland points [1]. National policy says development causing "the loss or deterioration of irreplaceable habitats (such as ancient woodland...)" should be refused unless there are wholly exceptional reasons [7]. In 2025 a planning inspector dismissed an appeal for a poultry unit on this ground. The inspector held that the permit threshold the applicant relies on "is not planning guidance", and that adding to levels that "are already high" is harm [8]. The same air-quality consultants acted for that appellant, so the argument the inspector rejected there is the one this application relies on.
In the Footbridge Farm appeal, the inspector added that already-exceeded levels are "not justification to make an undesirable situation even worse" [12]. So the woodland's existing overload is a reason to refuse, not a reason to accept more.
What a corrected baseline means. Added to the background, the new farm would take ammonia at the nearest woodland point to about 2.0 µg/m³, twice the safe limit (1.24 + 0.77) [1]. Even with today's farm overstated, the applicant's own tables show ammonia rising at North Exmoor SSSI (from 0.21% to 0.31% of the limit) and at South Exmoor SSSI, part of the Exmoor Heaths Special Area of Conservation (from 0.19% to 0.30%) [1]. With today's farm calculated on the government's factor, the "existing" figures at every point would fall, and more of them would show an increase. Only re-modelling can show by how much, and the applicant has not done it, so the claimed improvement at Exmoor's protected sites cannot be relied on.
Still nights carry ammonia to the woods. The detailed ammonia model leaves out calm conditions, because they "cannot be used with terrain", and relies on earlier runs made without terrain to say their effect "would not be significant" [1]. Our analysis of the ground shows that on still nights cold air drains from the sheds east, down the wooded valley towards Hole Water and the ancient woodland, 30–50 m below [30] (see Odour). So the very conditions most likely to carry ammonia from the sheds into the woods are the ones the model leaves out, and the 77–81% figure is likely to understate what the woods receive.
Exmoor's protected sites. The applicant's screening puts the farm's contribution at 3.6% of the limit at North Exmoor Site of Special Scientific Interest (SSSI) [1]. The applicant's own Ammonia Report says it is "a legal requirement to assess process contributions in-combination for habitats sites", unless the proposal reduces emissions or its contribution is below the Joint Nature Conservation Committee (JNCC) decision-making thresholds [1]. Emissions rise on the government's factors [3]. The applicant's predicted contribution at South Exmoor SSSI/SAC is 0.30% of the critical level [1]. That is above the JNCC thresholds for areas of high and medium development density (0.08% and 0.20%), but below those for low and very low density (0.34% and 0.75%), and the Ammonia Report does not say which applies [1]. The Exmoor National Park Authority says the nearby protected sites are already under pressure from nitrogen, and that the claimed improvement is "heavily reliant on the emission inventory assumptions" [1]. No in-combination assessment has been done, so unless the applicant shows that a lower-density threshold applies, NDC cannot rule out a likely significant effect, and cannot grant permission without an appropriate assessment showing no adverse effect on the sites' integrity.
04 · Odour
The applicant predicts that odour will fall at most homes, although bird numbers rise 4.4 times. That prediction is judged against a benchmark that no longer exists, rests on assumptions rather than measurement, and leaves out the places nearest the sheds.
Smell from broiler sheds is strongest late in each crop and when used litter is cleared out. The applicant's own EA risk assessment rates odour exposure during litter removal as "Likely" [2]. Brayford Parish Council reports that homes near the farm "are already impacted by the distinct and unpleasant odour" [1]. Odour of this kind stops people opening windows, using their gardens or hanging out washing, and a planning inspector has counted exposure in gardens as harm [12].
Odour harm already exists. The applicant's own model puts today's farm at 5.57 odour units at Braycross Cottages, above even the withdrawn pass mark of 3, and at 7.51 at the applicant's own farmhouse [1]. The Environmental Statement's answer is that "considerable tolerance of odour may develop, particularly in rural communities" [1]. So the starting point is already a problem, and neighbours are expected to get used to it rather than be protected from it.
An out-of-date benchmark. The applicant tests each home against a pass mark of 3 odour units, taken from EA guidance withdrawn in December 2025 [10]. Current planning guidance from the Institute of Air Quality Management (IAQM) treats livestock odour at a home as a "slight adverse" effect from 1.5 units and "moderate adverse" from 3 [11]. On the applicant's own figures, Braycross Cottages and High Bray remain in the adverse range, and odour rises at three places, including the Barns at Withygate wedding venue, so a home marked acceptable in the applicant's tables may be adverse under current guidance.

Assumptions, not measurement. None of the inputs that decide the result was measured at Higher Hall [1]:
Smell inside the sheds comes from a 2002 study and is the same for a 10,000-bird house as a 44,000-bird one, although the report itself says it depends on stocking density, so the smell from far more crowded sheds is likely understated.
Fans are modelled as three release points per shed, each releasing air at a fixed 11 metres a second in every hour of the year, including the hours when the model assumes only minimum ventilation [1]. Each shed would have 14 roof fans, and the applicant's noise report assumes only a quarter of them run at night [1]. How fast air would leave the fans at minimum ventilation, and how high the odour would rise on still nights, has not been tested.
Clean-out is given 2 hours a house, the same for houses 2.8 times today's size, although the applicant's own odour management plan allows up to 24 hours a house [2], so the smelliest part of each crop could last up to twelve times longer than modelled. The report admits there is "little available information on the magnitude of this peak emission". Spent litter waiting in emptied houses, dirty yards and wash water over the 7–10 day clear-out are not modelled.
Today's farm is modelled with its free-range field giving off odour every hour of the year, although birds only range in the second half of each crop, so today looks worse and the new farm looks better by comparison.
Weather Based on 4 years of past weather (2022–25), reconstructed by a global weather model on a grid about 7 km wide, not from the wind the applicant measured on site, which was near-still in 94% of night readings, so the model may not represent the nights air was almost still, the very nights that matter most.
The homes are 17 receptor points chosen by the consultant, 1.5 m above the ground [1]. One is Brayford Academy, though the results table calls it only “Brayford”; the report’s map places it at the “Education Facility” [1]. The village hall and pre-school, and the holiday let about 8 m from the installation, are not among their receptors.
High ventilation. The model lowers the smell inside the sheds when ventilation is high. The independent review finds this adjustment “has not been adequately justified and could materially influence the predicted odour impacts” [1].
A promise with a get-out. The Environmental Statement's mitigation for clean-out is to "Avoid clearing if the wind direction is blowing in the direction of near neighbours if at all possible" [1]. Homes lie north-west, north, north-east and south-west of the sheds. So in most winds a neighbour is downwind, and "if at all possible" makes the promise unenforceable.
Gable fans face the village. Each shed also has gable-end fans. The noise report calls them "emergency" units, but the Environmental Statement says they are for summer use, and the air models assume they carry half the emissions whenever it is above 23°C [1]. On the two western sheds they face west, towards Brayford [1]. So on warm days, when people are outdoors and windows are open, odour and fan noise would be pushed towards the village.
Of its manure, the applicant says "The EIA [Environmental Impact Assessment] does not accept conjecture" [1]. Its odour case should meet the same standard.
The worst hours are hidden. The figures show the level exceeded in the worst 2% of hours, about 175 hours a year. They say nothing about how bad those hours are, so the short, intense episodes residents actually notice, such as clean-out and catching, are averaged away. The same consultants have reported short-term figures for clean-out elsewhere [13]. In the Footbridge Farm appeal, the inspector would not rely on an assessment by the same modeller that "fails to consider peak odour concentrations at the end of the growing cycle and during the clearing out" [12].
Still nights. The applicant's own weather station recorded wind of 1 metre a second or less in 135 of 144 night readings (94%) [1]. Historical weather data for the site gives 139–354 still, clear night hours a year in 2022–25 [14]. On cool nights the odour model assumes only minimum ventilation, and the applicant's noise report assumes only a quarter of the roof fans run at night [1], yet the model keeps air leaving at a high 11 m/s. Whether it would leave that fast has not been shown, and if it leaves more slowly the smell rises less. Cold air also drains downhill towards Braycross, Brayford and the wooded valley to the east, and the odour report does not mention cold-air drainage [1], so the nights when odour is most likely to reach homes have not been assessed.
Our own analysis of still nights
Using the EA's 2 m resolution ground survey [30], we traced the routes cold air would take downhill from the sheds. They split two ways:
West: past Braycross Cottages, about 27 m below the sheds, then through Brayford to the floor of the River Bray valley, about 70 m below.
East: past Higher Hall and Lower Hall, then down the wooded valley towards Hole Water and the ancient woodland, 30–50 m below the sheds.
We then ran a simple screening calculation using the applicant’s own figures, with a light wind and still night air, allowing for the lift the warm chimney air gives the smell. The answer depends on how the sheds are run. With air leaving every chimney at 11 m/s, as the model assumes, the smell settles about 30 m up and does not reach the ground within 1.3 km. If the fans are slowed, it rises only about 17 m and reaches the ground from about 480 m, with hourly levels of about 4 to 9 odour units at the village hall, the school playground, Lower Hall, The Bungalow, the Old Baptist Chapel and Withygate Barns. If smell leaves at ground level, through open doors for example, homes within about 800 m see more than 10. These are indicative screening figures, not a full model. A flat-ground calculation also leaves out the three ways smell comes down in real life: cold air draining downhill, the morning break-up of the night layer, and air caught behind the roofs. So the result rests on fan speed and how the air leaves the sheds, which the applicant assumed rather than tested. See Where does the farm air go? for illustrations of each case.
Three of the applicant's own receptor points, two in Brayford and one at Beara Hill, sit within 2 m of a valley floor where cold air collects [30]. So odour carried downhill on still nights would gather where people live.
If the prediction is wrong. The EA's replacement guidance sets no odour limit. Once a farm is running, reports from affected people are "the only direct way" to judge harm [10]. If the prediction proves wrong, the evidence will come from Brayford's homes, school, holiday let, village hall and wedding venue patrons, after the sheds are built, when it is too late to prevent harm.
05 · Night-time noise, lorries, catching and thinning
The noise report assesses the ventilation fans only. It leaves out lorries, loading and bird catching because, it says, the development “will not result in any change to the frequency or nature of transport movements” [1]. The applicant’s own figures show lorry trips per crop more than doubling (see Lorries), and its EA noise assessment states “Bird catching frequently occurring during night time”, with reversing alarms during night catching [2].
Nights here are very quiet: the applicant measured background noise of 25 decibels (dB) at night [1]. Catching brings crews, forklifts, lorries and reversing alarms into that silence. Sudden noise at night wakes people and disturbs sleep, which is why such peaks are normally assessed separately. No peak-noise assessment was done, so the noise most likely to wake people is unmeasured.
The same consultant assessed it elsewhere. For a poultry unit at Wrawby Farm, Lincolnshire, prepared for the same agent in 2025, the same acoustic consultant assessed night catching. It used measured catching noise of 62 dB, with peaks of 79 dB, at 20 m, for homes 510–585 m away [15]. At Higher Hall, with homes from 150 m away, catching was not assessed at all, so leaving it out here was a choice, not a limit of the method.
What that would mean here. Scaled by distance alone, as sound falls by about 6 dB each time the distance doubles, peaks of 79 dB at 20 m would still be about 60 dB at 150 m: more than 35 dB above the 25 dB night background [1][15]. As a rule of thumb, every 10 dB sounds about twice as loud. Hedges, buildings and the ground would reduce that, which is exactly why the noise needed to be measured and assessed, not left out.
An unmentioned second catch. The applicant says the sheds will run at 30 kilogrammes of chicken per square metre (kg/m²) [1]. The law allows up to 33 kg/m², or up to 39 kg/m² where extra conditions are met [16]. The application never names the breed or slaughter weight, or shows how 30 kg/m² is achieved, so the operation actually proposed cannot be checked.
On a standard breed's growth, 176,000 birds would pass 30 kg/m² around day 29–30 and the legal limit around day 35 [17]. To stay at 30 kg/m², about 54,000 birds, nearly a third, would have to be caught and removed early. That practice, called thinning, is lawful and common. It means a second catching night in every crop, with more lorries, doors opened and litter disturbed when odour is near its peak. Thinning is mentioned once in passing in the permit documents [2] and assessed nowhere, so a second catching night every crop is missing from the noise, odour and traffic figures.
A comparable unit, Penhros Farm in Herefordshire (four sheds of 42,000 birds), thins "just under a third" of its birds at just over four weeks [37]. So the second catch is normal practice for a unit like this, not a theoretical risk.
The standby generator, tested weekly, feed deliveries blown into silos and clean-out machinery are not assessed either [1][2], so regular sources of noise beyond the fans are left out.
Lorries in the village. New lorries of the required size must pass a standard acceleration test at no more than 79–82 dB(A), measured 7.5 m away [51]. On the route, 9 front doors open beside the carriageway, 2 of them straight onto it. A metre or two from a passing lorry the level is roughly 10–15 dB higher: around 90 dB, from a lorry that meets the strictest standard. Every loaded lorry would climb somewhere on the route. Lorries leaving with birds, manure or dirty water would cross the village bridge one vehicle at a time, then climb an incline of about 7% to the A399, stop at the junction and pull out round a bend. Feed and gas lorries would climb from the village up to the farm. A loaded lorry pulling away or climbing works its engine harder than the standard test thereby making more noise, none of this was assessed during the day or night, because the noise report leaves lorries out altogether.
06 · Lorries through Brayford
On the applicant's own figures, lorry and tractor-trailer trips would rise from about 163 a year to 459–488, nearly three times today [1]. Devon County Council (DCC) Highways raised no objection because it was told the traffic was "not considered to be materially different than the existing" [1].
Per crop, feed lorries rise from 7 to 26, lorries taking birds to slaughter from 6 to 22, chick deliveries from 1 to 4 and gas deliveries from 1 to 3 [1]. Professional guidance from the Institute of Environmental Management and Assessment (IEMA) says roads should be assessed where heavy goods vehicles increase by more than 30% [18]. Here they increase by about 180–200%, six times the level at which assessment is expected. The original Transport Statement had no author, date, route or assessment [1]. A Technical Statement by Trace Design, issued in November, now calls the rise a “minimal increase” [1]. It reaches that by comparing one crop with one crop (29.5 to 65.5 trips, itself a 122% rise) and ignores the extra crops each year, so it understates the yearly increase and still assesses neither the route nor the school.
The A399 junction. Police records show three injury collisions at the Brayford junction with the A399 between December 2022 and August 2025, two of them serious, with six people hurt, two of them children [46]. In two, a car overturned; one of those was in the dark, on ice, on a road surface the police recorded as defective [46]. No lorry was involved, but the junction is on the applicant's own construction route [1], and lorry movements would nearly treble. The new Technical Statement reports only two serious collisions near the junction. It records the April 2025 collision as serious, when police recorded it as slight, and it misses the serious collision of August 2025 [1][46]. It finds “no particular pattern” and “no existing highway safety concerns to mitigate”, so its safety conclusion rests on an incomplete record.
A single road that runs past the school. Every lorry from the A399 would pass through Brayford, past Brayford Academy and the village hall, which the school uses for parking [1]. Residents measure the lane at the Old Post Office at about 3.5 m from wall to kerb, with no pavement. A 2.55 m lorry leaves less than 50 cm on each side. Walkers, cyclists, horse riders and children share these lanes. More lorries mean more noise, vibration, mud on the road, damaged verges, potholes and risk to people on foot.
The alternative route. The Parish Council describes the route via Holewater and Beara Hill as having steep gradients, restricted visibility and limited passing places, and says it can become icy and is not gritted [1]. The route runs along the edge of Exmoor National Park for about 1.9 miles, then inside the Park for about 1.7 miles over Yarde Down to Yardewells Cross, before joining the A399 near North Molton. The Technical Statement does not say which route lorries would use [1], so routing lorries this way would move the problem into the National Park.
The school has objected. On 11 November the Head of School wrote on behalf of Brayford Academy, raising air quality, asthma, heavy lorries near school drop-off, drainage and biosecurity, and asking that these are “fully assessed, with particular regard to the school’s location” [1]. So the school the lorries would pass is itself asking for the assessment that has not been done.
Bunched at the end of each crop. The 22 bird lorries per crop come on a few catching days, and the manure and dirty-water lorries follow at clean-out [1]. Bird lorries often run at night (see Night-time noise). Only one dirty-water lorry per crop is noted [1], although washing the sheds would produce roughly 170,000–190,000 litres of dirty water at each clean-out [49], so tanker trips are likely to be undercounted.
Construction. Building would take about 46 weeks, with all construction traffic routed through Brayford [1]. No vehicle numbers are given, so 46 weeks of construction traffic through the village is unassessed.
07 · Manure: where does it go?
The farm would produce roughly 1,800 to 3,200 tonnes of used litter a year, and the application does not say where any of it goes. That figure is scaled from two comparable poultry units, at 11 and 18 tonnes per 1,000 bird places a year [19][20], because the applicant does not say how much litter the farm would produce. No figure of how much, no clear statement as to where it goes. The projected manure would contain roughly 33 to 58 tonnes of nitrogen a year.
Litter is wood shavings mixed with droppings. Wherever it is stored or spread, it gives off odour and ammonia, attracts flies, and can wash nitrogen and phosphorus into streams. Here, the nearest streams feed Hole Water and the River Bray.
Four or more destinations, none named. The documents variously say the litter will be [1][2]:
sold to an unnamed anaerobic digestion (AD) plant;
spread by unnamed third parties;
taken by neighbouring farms under an agreement that is not supplied;
used "on operator controlled land as fertiliser", although the permit form says it will not be;
kept in temporary field heaps.
No tonnage, contract or route is given. The Environmental Statement declines to assess spreading: "Any further details on the location of land used for spreading are assumptions only... The EIA does not accept conjecture" [1]. The application's eight manure lorries a crop would each need to carry 31–57 tonnes, against a typical load of about 27–30 tonnes [20]. Either the farm would produce far less litter than comparable units, or the lorry and noise figures are understated.
The courts have rejected this approach. In Squire (2019), the Court of Appeal quashed permission for a four-shed broiler unit because its assessment left out the odour and dust from storing and spreading its manure off site. The court noted that the EA's permit does not control what happens outside the farm boundary [21]. The Supreme Court in Finch (2024) held that assuming another regime will deal with an effect "does not remove the obligation to identify and assess" it [22]. In Caffyn (2025), the High Court quashed permission for a 200,000-bird unit. It held that sending manure to an AD plant does not end the duty to assess the digestate, and that even unknown destinations can be assessed "at a relatively high level of generality" [19], so a permission granted without assessing the litter would be open to the same challenge.
NDC itself has controlled manure spreading at this farm by planning condition since 2006 [1]. It cannot now treat the destination of the litter from 4.4 times as many birds as unknowable.
08 · Water, drainage and groundwater
The drainage scheme would soak run-off from about 1.7 hectares of roofs and yards into the ground above a sensitive aquifer. The report that should justify it is missing, and the figures that are available are inconsistent.
Run-off from poultry yards carries dust, droppings, spilt feed and disinfectant. If it is not contained, it can reach springs, wells and private water supplies, and from there Hole Water and the River Bray, which local angling clubs say support salmon and trout [1].
Report not published; the flood authority objects. The Environmental Statement quotes a flood risk assessment and drainage strategy “provided in Appendix 1”. It is not among the published documents [1]. The Lead Local Flood Authority, which has seen it, objects: on 4 November it found the scheme does not satisfactorily conform to Local Plan policy ST03 and asked for more information [1]. It asks the applicant to state the site’s gradient, because infiltration should not be used on slopes steeper than 1 in 10; to show overland exceedance routes across the whole site, not just from the basin and soakaway; to show the roof-water reuse tank on a drawing; and to rerun the calculations with current rainfall data (FEH 2022, not FEH 2013). It also notes a low to medium risk of surface-water flooding beside the existing building in the north-east of the site [1]. So the body responsible for drainage has not accepted the design, and the public cannot check it.
Ground tested in the wrong places. The basin is sized on an infiltration rate of 0.837 metres an hour from a pit beside the gas tanks. The Environmental Statement says it used "the nearest pit", but on the applicant's own drawing a pit between Units 1 and 3, at 0.296 metres an hour, is closer to the basin [1], so the basin’s design has not been checked against the slower result. Neither pit is within about 75 metres of the basin or the soakaway, and a third pit is mentioned but not shown [1], so no test shows how the ground drains where the water will go. Devon County Council's drainage guidance asks for groundwater monitoring, ideally over a year, wherever infiltration is proposed [45]. None is reported, so there is no evidence of the clear metre of ground needed above the water table.
Three stories for clean water. The documents send it to the basin, to soakaways and an off-site ditch, or to a tank for reuse [1][2]. The dirty-water tanks are described as 62,000 or 63,000 litres, and as underground or above ground [1][2]. Washing the sheds after each crop would produce roughly 170,000–190,000 litres [49], nearly three times what the tanks hold, and the Transport Statement allows for one dirty-water lorry a crop [1], so no one can say where clean or contaminated water will end up.
Sensitive groundwater, no monitoring. The site lies over an aquifer the EA classes as Secondary A, with high vulnerability [2]. The western half drains to the Bray (Source to Hole Water), a water body protected for drinking water [23]. The Environmental Statement mentions none of this, and the permit documents state "No monitoring will be undertaken" [2], so contamination would go undetected. Residents know of springs and wells downhill at Braycross.
Overflow route. In a heavy storm or a blockage, overflow from the basin would run north-east, downhill towards Hole Water and the ancient woodland. That route is not assessed [1], so a failure could carry polluted water towards the woodland and Hole Water unchecked.
Water supply. No document states how much water the birds need or where it comes from. On standard figures, drinking water alone would be about 1.1 to 1.2 million litres a crop, or 22–24 cubic metres a day [17][24]. That is the average: birds drink 6–7% more for each degree above 21°C [48], and washing the four sheds after each crop takes roughly 170,000–190,000 litres more [49]. Taking more than 20 cubic metres a day from a borehole or spring is likely to need an abstraction licence [25]. From the mains, it is a question of South West Water's capacity, so the effect on springs, private supplies or SWW's public network is unknown.
Chemicals and medicines. The permit inventory lists 13 disinfectants and biocides, including 480 litres of formalin a year, three antibiotics and weedkiller [2]. Wash water carries the disinfectants, and medicine residues can pass into the litter, yet neither is assessed for the aquifer, the springs or the land the litter is spread on.
A river already under pressure. Brayford sewage works discharged storm sewage into the River Bray 172 times in 2025, the fifth longest of South West Water's 334 treatment works (Environment Agency event duration monitoring returns; overflow SBB00148) [44]. It discharges into the same protected water body the western half of the site drains to [23], so the river would take both the village's overflow and the farm's run-off and manure risk, and the application assesses neither together.
09 · Exmoor, landscape, dark skies and tourism
The Environmental Statement admits a "moderate adverse residual visual effect" but calls it "not a significant change" [1]. It reaches that view without a landscape and visual impact assessment (LVIA), without viewpoints, and without once mentioning Exmoor National Park, so the effect on Exmoor's setting is asserted, not assessed.
Devon CPRE has objected on the same ground. It finds that Chapter 13 sets out no landscape and visual baseline, identifies no receptors or viewpoints, and explains neither its method nor how its conclusions were reached, and asks NDC to confirm whether its validation list requires a landscape and visual impact assessment [1]. It also notes that the two site sections do not show where the largest changes in level occur, and that no cut-and-fill calculation shows the 66,000 tonnes of excavated soil would balance on site [1], so neither the visual effects nor the scale of the earthworks can be judged from what has been submitted.
Exmoor National Park. The park boundary follows Holewater Hill, about 200 m north of the sheds. National policy requires development in the setting of protected landscapes to be "sensitively located and designed to avoid or minimise adverse impacts" [7]. The Local Plan says proposals affecting the park's setting "will not be permitted where it would conflict with the achievement of their statutory purposes" [26]. Natural England's response says an LVIA "should be provided" where impacts may be significant [1], so NDC has no evidence on which to apply either test.
Scale. Four sheds over 100 m long, eight 9 m feed silos and an 8.2 m storage building would replace four smaller houses, extending into an undeveloped field [1]. The application form says the site cannot be seen from any public road or footpath [1]. Residents see it from Holewater Hill and Whitefield Lane, and the Exmoor National Park Authority confirms the existing sheds are visible from higher ground within the National Park, including Whitefield Lane [1], so the visual case starts from a false premise.
Dark skies. The site is close to the Exmoor Dark Sky Reserve, which the Local Plan names as "particularly sensitive to light pollution" [26]. The Environmental Statement describes both a single 30-watt floodlight and security lights of up to 150 watts, and never mentions the Reserve [1], so the effect of lighting on the Reserve is unassessed. Night catching means lit yards and lorries several nights each crop.
Heritage. Seven listed buildings lie within 1 km, including the Grade I Church of All Saints at High Bray [1]. There is no heritage statement, so the effect on the setting of the Grade I church is unassessed. DCC's Historic Environment Team has identified a possible prehistoric enclosure, prehistoric flints and Romano-British iron-working nearby, contradicting the Environmental Statement's claim of "no historic evidence" [1].
Tourism. The applicant claims a gain of two full-time jobs [1]. The Environmental Statement does not mention tourism once. Exmoor National Park drew 1.6 million visits in 2024, worth £242 million and supporting 2,377 full-time-equivalent jobs [27]. The Local Plan describes northern Devon's tourism as "based on and sustained by its natural and built environment" [26]. Holiday lets around Brayford advertise the same things: Exmoor on the doorstep, walks from the door including the Tarka Trail, the River Bray, peace and quiet, and dark skies, so the economic case sets two jobs against a visitor economy the Environmental Statement never considers.
The Barns at Withygate, a wedding venue opened in 2025, holds ceremonies outdoors [28]. Its owners have objected that a wedding "cannot simply be postponed" if the wind brings odour on the day [1]. Visitors staying or celebrating here are exposed to the same odour, noise and lorries as residents, and none of the assessments considers them. Holiday-let owners in the village have also written to NDC about the effect on their bookings and income [1].
10 · Gaps in the Environmental Statement
A unit of more than 85,000 broilers must have an Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA). NDC cannot grant permission without examining the Environmental Statement and reaching a reasoned conclusion on the significant effects [29]. The statement supplied falls short of what the law requires.
What the law requires [29] | What the Environmental Statement provides | Effect on the decision |
A non-technical summary | None | Residents have no plain account of the effects to comment on |
The reasonable alternatives studied, the reasons for the option chosen, and a comparison of their effects | A chapter headed "Alternative Sites" that describes none, only need. The Design and Access Statement says scale, siting and design were "carefully considered" [1] | NDC cannot tell whether the claimed need could be met with less harm, which matters where ancient woodland requires "wholly exceptional reasons" [7] |
Indirect effects | Manure spreading and wash water refused as "conjecture" | Where 1,800–3,200 tonnes of litter a year end up, and what they do there, is never weighed |
Cumulative effects with other projects | None: no other farms, no Brayford Quarry | The quarry's dust and night working, and other farms' ammonia, are never added to the farm's own effects |
Effects on water quantity and quality | No water demand, groundwater or water-quality assessment; drainage appendix missing | Risks to springs, wells, the aquifer and the River Bray are unknown |
Effects on population and human health | No bioaerosol or night-noise assessment; the village hall left out of every assessment, the school out of the noise assessment | What children and neighbours would breathe and hear at night is unassessed |
Landscape and cultural heritage | No LVIA, no setting assessment; archaeology contradicted by DCC | The effect on Exmoor's setting and on listed buildings is asserted, not assessed |
"The main uncertainties involved" in its forecasts | Not stated, although the odour report admits "little available information" on the clean-out peak | NDC cannot judge how far to trust predictions whose weaknesses are not disclosed |
Dust and bioaerosols. The Environmental Statement admits the daily limit for fine dust (PM10) "may be exceeded very close to the poultry houses, specifically near the gable end fans" [1]. Dust from poultry sheds carries particles of feather, skin and droppings, with bacteria and fungal spores (bioaerosols). The fine fraction can be breathed deep into the lungs. The EA requires a dust and bioaerosol plan wherever people live within 100 m [4]. That plan lists only Exmoor View, describes it as a "staff dwelling", although its only planning permission limits it to holiday accommodation and rules out permanent residential use (NDC 35127, condition 6) [1], and relies on a bioaerosol assessment that has not been supplied [2], so the bioaerosol risk to people near the sheds has not been assessed.
Inconsistencies in the application [1][2]:
bird numbers of 176,000, 173,926 and 172,728, so it is unclear what NDC would be permitting;
five different chimney heights, from 5.5 m to 6.95 m, while the air models use 6.2 m, so the height actually built would decide where odour and ammonia land;
ancillary buildings said to be for "a future planning application", while the drawings seek them now, so buildings sought in this application are not assessed in it;
the storage building labelled "Heating/Pyrolysis Building" on one drawing, while the Environmental Statement says heating will be by gas, so a combustion or pyrolysis use would bring emissions that no one has assessed;
an application form answering "No" to trees or hedges on site, nearby watercourses, protected species and important habitats, and visibility from public places, each contradicted by the applicant's own reports, so the application was checked against incorrect answers.
11 · Health
The application treats health as a food-safety question. It does not assess what neighbours, visitors and schoolchildren would breathe or hear. National policy requires decisions to take account of the effects of pollution on health and living conditions, including "where certain groups could be particularly vulnerable... such as children and older people" [7].
Ammonia. Breathing ammonia, even at low levels, can irritate the eyes, nose and throat, and levels are higher where there is a lot of animal waste [5]. In the air it reacts with other pollutants to form fine particles, which raise major health concerns [6].
Dust. On the EA's standard factor of 0.1 kg per bird a year, dust from the sheds would rise from about 4 tonnes a year today to about 17.6 tonnes [1]. Poultry dust is made of bedding, feed, droppings and feather particles, and carries bacteria, fungal spores and their toxins (bioaerosols). The finest fraction is breathed deep into the lungs.
Bioaerosols. A 2018 systematic review found mixed results for communities near intensive farms, but higher reported asthma among children living or going to school near them, from a small number of studies [31]. Dutch government research found reduced lung function among people living near large numbers of livestock farms, linked to ammonia in the air, and signs that fine particles from the farms make people more susceptible to infections [32]. No bioaerosol assessment has been supplied for Higher Hall [2].
Disease. The Environmental Statement rates the risk to nearby homes from Campylobacter, Salmonella and avian influenza as "Negligible", on the basis of food-chain and biosecurity controls [1]. It does not consider airborne routes or the people living closest.
Sleep and wellbeing. Night catching, reversing alarms and lorries in a 25 dB background, and odour on still nights when windows are open, fall on people when they are trying to sleep. Neither is assessed (see Odour and Night-time noise). A 2021 review of 30 studies of people living near industrial odour sources - 13 of them livestock units - found more headaches and coughs among those exposed, most studies relied on self-reported symptoms and are likely under-reported [47].
Our youngest. Brayford Academy's grounds are about 370 m away and the village hall and pre-school about 335 m [1][2]. None is named in the odour, dust or noise assessments, so the children and families who use them are outside every assessment.
12 · Brayford Quarry and combined effects
The application assesses the farm on its own, as if nothing else affected the same air, roads and people. The law requires an Environmental Statement to assess cumulative effects with other existing and approved projects [29]. This one does not [1].
Brayford Quarry. Brayford Quarry, about 1 km south-west of the nearest shed, and about 1 km from Brayford Academy and the village hall (local residents' measurements), has crushing operations and an asphalt plant, and is not mentioned anywhere in the application. The applicant's own dust report shows the highest background fine dust (PM10) in the area, 11.29 µg/m³, in the 1 km square that contains the quarry [1]. Asphalt plants give off dust, fumes and bitumen odour. In May 2026 the quarry operator applied to run the asphalt plant at night, on up to 50 nights a year until the end of 2029 [33], so residents could face quarry night working and farm night catching on the same nights, with neither weighed against the other.
Combined effects on the same people. The homes, school and businesses of Brayford would receive several effects at once: odour and dust from the sheds and the manure, dust from the quarry, night catching and lorries, more lorries on the one road through the village, and light in a dark-sky area. Each is assessed on its own, if at all. None is assessed together, so the true burden on the village is never seen.
Other farms. Natural England's advice says an in-combination assessment must include other projects or activities that could affect the same protected sites [9]. None has been done, and no other poultry or livestock units within 5 km or 10 km have been considered, so the in-combination test for those sites cannot be met.
13 · Emergencies
The law requires an Environmental Statement to assess the risks of accidents and disasters [29]. This one covers disease only through the food chain, and the permit documents rate every hazard "Not significant" [1][2].
Each event below is credible on a unit of this size, and for each the application gives no plan, or only a partial one. That is why a rating of "Not significant" cannot be relied on.
Disease outbreak. An outbreak of avian influenza or another notifiable disease would mean culling every bird on site. At the end of a crop the sheds would hold roughly 440 tonnes of live birds (about 171,000 birds at about 2.6 kg each). The permit documents say high-mortality losses would go "at an approved landfill site under the advice of that veterinarian" [2]. Where they would be held, how they would leave and by which route is not stated, so up to 440 tonnes of carcasses could be stored on site and taken through the village by a route and timetable no one has assessed.
Everyday losses. About 5,300 birds die in a normal crop (3%) [2]. They would be held in a 4 m by 4 m "Dead Bird/ Freezer Building" [1]. Collection is described as once every two crops, "twice weekly" and "regularly" in different documents [1][2], so neither the size of the store nor the number of collection vehicles can be checked.
Power or ventilation failure. Housed birds depend on fans, and the law requires a back-up that keeps air moving if they fail, with an alarm that works without mains power [16]. The permit papers disagree on what that back-up is. The Emergency Plan says the site has a generator; the Odour Management Plan says a mobile generator would be "sourced within 4 hrs" [2]. No planning drawing shows a generator, nothing shows one could run the fans of all four houses, and the Accident Assessment does not consider power failure at all [1][2], so a single equipment failure in hot weather could become a mass-mortality event, with no tested plan for the birds, the odour or the carcasses.
Dirty water. At clean-out, a hand-operated valve diverts wash water from the drainage system to the dirty-water tanks [1]. If it is not switched over, contaminated water goes to the infiltration basin above the aquifer; if it is not switched back, clean water fills the tanks, so one missed turn of a valve could put wash water, disinfectant and droppings into the ground above a drinking-water catchment.
14 · After an approval: who protects residents?
If permission and an EA permit are granted, residents will depend on the permit rules and making complaints for protection from harm. Experience elsewhere shows how weak that protection can be, which is why the planning decision matters.
How the permit works. The permit's odour condition is judged by an EA officer who must detect the odour beyond the boundary, but an operator following its own approved odour management plan can use it as a defence [10]. The only routine check proposed is a weekly boundary "sniff test" by the operator's own staff, recorded on the farm [2]. Intensive farms get up to 14 days' notice of an EA inspection, and farms in the EA's Pig and Poultry Assurance Scheme are inspected by the EA only once every three years, with a certification body inspecting in the other two [34], so EA inspections are unlikely to coincide with a breach.
Enforcement in practice. The Bureau of Investigative Journalism found more than 3,000 breaches of environmental rules at intensive livestock farms in England many of them dealt with by "advice and guidance" rather than sanctions [35], so residents cannot count on enforcement to stop a problem quickly.
What neighbours of other broiler units report:
Hollins Lane, Shropshire (235,000 birds): residents of Tyrley, about 460 m away, reported more than 80 odour complaints. The EA said the operations complied with its permit [36], so a farm can meet its permit and still leave neighbours nearly ½ km away living with odour.
Penhros Farm, Herefordshire (four sheds of 42,000 birds, comparable in size to Higher Hall Farm): a neighbour about 235 m away described a "horrible sweet sickly smell" from the ventilation chimneys, "24/7", and lorries at night [37].
Footbridge Farm, Shropshire (210,000 places): permission was quashed by the Court of Appeal and a later appeal dismissed, so the unit was never built [12][21].
Banham Poultry, Norfolk: a poultry abattoir rather than a farm, but it shows the timescale. It was fined £300,000 in 2022 for odour after hundreds of complaints between 2019 and 2021 [38], so even successful enforcement can take years.
Nuisance law is a last resort. Planning permission does not license a nuisance, and neighbours can still go to court [39]. The council can also act on statutory nuisance, but trade premises have a "best practicable means" defence [40]. Both put the cost, delay and burden of proof on residents after the harm has started. Planning policy exists to prevent that at the decision stage [7].
15 · The official responses: what each relied on, and what it did not address
Several consultees raised no objection. Between them, the five that did so leave 22 errors, omissions or inconsistencies unaddressed, and Natural England's response leaves four more: 26 across six responses. Each response rests on the applicant's documents, and each relied on figures or premises that this report shows to be wrong or incomplete. A "no objection" carries weight only for the reasons it gives. In the Footbridge Farm appeal, the inspector held that the regulatory officers' lack of concern "does not alter my findings", and that Natural England's non-objection did not change the harm found [12]. All responses below are on the public file [1].
› NDC Environmental Health (18 Sep 2026): no objection
The decision relied on: the odour report's prediction that the proposal is "likely to reduce odour impacts compared with the existing situation", and the noise and dust reports.
Not addressed, or relied on wrongly:
the odour pass mark was withdrawn in December 2025, and current guidance treats lower levels as adverse [10][11], so homes the report passes would now be rated adverse;
the predicted fall depends on today's free-range field giving off odour every hour of the year, although birds only range in the second half of each crop, which inflates today's figures and so the size of the predicted fall;
clean-out is modelled at 2 hours a house, while the applicant's own odour management plan allows up to 24 hours a house after each crop [2], so the smelliest part of each crop could be up to twelve times longer than modelled;
the air is assumed to leave all twelve chimneys at a fixed 11 m/s every hour, although the fans are variable-speed and only about a quarter are expected to run at night [1], so on still nights odour would rise less and reach homes in stronger concentrations than predicted;
the noise report excludes lorries and night catching on a premise the applicant's own figures contradict [1][2], leaving out the night-time noise most likely to annoy and wake neighbours;
the condition it recommends ties the ventilation to the noise report, which models Big Dutchman FF091-6ET roof fans, while the plant specification lists DA 820 chimney fans [1], so the condition would require different fans from those the applicant specifies;
the village hall was not assessed, Brayford Academy appears only as an unnamed point in the odour and dust models and not at all in the noise assessment, and no bioaerosol assessment was supplied [2], so the effects on children and the village’s main meeting place are not properly known.
To the EA, the same team described the proposal as "a major increase in the scale and intensity" of operations, with buildings "significantly closer to a number of existing residential properties" [2]. Those concerns are not answered by a report that predicts less odour from more than four times the birds.
› Environment Agency (18 Sep 2026): no objection
The decision relied on: the need for a separate permit. The response contains no site-specific assessment.
Not addressed:
the permit controls only what happens inside the installation [21], so manure once it leaves the site, traffic and land use fall to NDC, and no one has assessed them;
in its own permit review, the EA found ancient woodland within 250 m that its earlier screening had missed, and asked for detailed modelling [2], yet the "revised" ammonia report then supplied has the same text as the May version [1][2], so the question the EA raised has not been answered.
› Natural England (1 Oct 2026): no conclusion reached
Said: the potential for air-quality impacts "needs to be assessed" under its standing advice, the conclusion is for NDC, and a landscape and visual impact assessment should be provided where impacts may be significant [1].
Not addressed:
no assessment to Natural England's standing advice has been done, so NDC has nothing on which to reach the conclusion left to it;
the claimed exemption from in-combination assessment depends on an emissions reduction that disappears when calculated with the government’s factors [3], and the contribution at South Exmoor SSSI/SAC (0.30%) is below the JNCC threshold only if a low-density threshold applies, which the applicant has not shown [1], so an in-combination assessment is still needed and has not been done;
the screening and detailed models differ more than tenfold at North Exmoor SSSI, without explanation [1], so the lower figure the applicant relies on is untested;
no landscape and visual impact assessment has been provided, so the effect on the setting of Exmoor National Park is unassessed.
› DCC Highways (15 Oct 2026): no objection, no conditions
The decision relied on: traffic "not considered to be materially different than the existing", "lightly trafficked roads", a "low speed environment" and the existing access [1].
Not addressed, or relied on wrongly:
lorry trips per crop rise from 29.5 to 65.5, nearly trebling over a year [1], so “not considered to be materially different than the existing” is contradicted by the applicant’s own figures;
it cites the Local Plan as "2022-2031", but the plan period is 2011–2031 [26], so the policy basis it relied on is unclear;
construction traffic, time of day, the school, the pinch points and the routes of litter and wash water were not considered, so the effects on the one road through Brayford, at the times that matter most, are unassessed;
professional guidance says roads should be assessed where heavy vehicles rise by more than 30% [18], and here the rise is about 180–200%.
a Technical Statement by Trace Design (Nov 2026) now relies on Highways’ response, concluding “It is very clear that the highway authority have no traffic and highway issues” [1], while Highways relied on the original transport statement, so each relies on the other and neither assesses the route;
the Technical Statement describes Holewater Hill as a “derestricted Class C road” [1], so the “low speed environment” Highways relied on is contradicted by the applicant’s own consultant.
› South West Water (18 Sep 2026): infiltration acceptable in principle
The decision relied on: infiltration's place at the top of the drainage hierarchy. It gave no view on infiltration rates, groundwater or water quality [1].
Not addressed:
the drainage report is missing [1], so the design cannot be checked;
a second test pit drained 2.8 times more slowly than the rate used [1], so the basin’s design has not been checked against the slower result:
no groundwater monitoring is reported, although Devon's guidance asks for it wherever infiltration is proposed [45], so the clearance above the water table is unknown;
the site lies over a highly vulnerable aquifer, partly in a drinking-water catchment [2][23], so a failure could reach springs, wells and a protected water body.
› NDC Sustainability (23 Sep 2026): no objection, subject to conditions
The decision relied on: the biodiversity net gain metric [1].
Not addressed:
ammonia on ancient woodland and Exmoor's protected sites, the largest ecological effect, which the metric does not measure;
the net gain statement answers "No" to avoiding or mitigating harm to high-value habitats on site [1], so the first steps of the mitigation hierarchy were skipped;
one survey visit in February, outside the best season [1], so species and habitats may be under-recorded;
about 130 m of species-rich hedgerow, a priority habitat, would be lost [1], replaced by planting that takes years to mature;
the ecology report's section on designated sites ends mid-sentence [1], so its conclusion on those sites is missing.
› DCC Historic Environment Team (28 Sep and 12 Oct 2026): investigation required
It asks for a written scheme of archaeological investigation before a decision, or conditions. It describes the western extension as "a greenfield undeveloped site" with potential to destroy archaeological deposits [1]. This contradicts the Environmental Statement's "no historic evidence" and its claim that the sheds sit "within the footprint of the existing buildings", so the applicant's description of the site cannot be relied on.
› DCC Waste Planning (22 Sep and 29 Oct 2026): revised audit accepted
It asked for disposal tonnages and sites [1]. The revised audit (Rev A, 16 October) gives 68,320 tonnes in all, with 66,000 tonnes of soil reused on site, though its rows still do not fully reconcile [1]. On 29 October Waste Planning accepted it, noting that disposal sites are not yet known and asking that they be as close to the site as possible [1]. Its review covers construction and demolition waste only. For waste from the running farm, the audit refers back to the Environmental Statement, which gives no manure tonnage [1]. So the one consultee that reviewed waste was not asked about the largest waste stream, the manure.
› Brayford Parish Council (29 Sep 2026 and 30 Oct 2026): objection
In September it raised the scale, narrow lanes, lorries past the school and village hall, night lorries, existing odour, manure and dark skies, and asked that avoidable lorry movements be barred between 19:00 and 07:00 [1]. On 30 October it formally objected, finding Higher Hall Farm “not an appropriate location for a development of this nature and scale”. It adds that the alternative route via Holewater and Beara Hill has steep gradients, restricted visibility and limited passing places and can become icy, that the farm’s egg-laying shed generates traffic of its own, and that there are “too many unanswered questions” about how the development would operate [1].
› Exmoor National Park Authority (27 Oct 2026): comment, with concerns
It confirms the site is immediately outside the National Park, that the existing sheds are visible from higher ground within it, including Whitefield Lane, and that the landscape plan does not address boundary hedge management [1]. It warns that lighting could harm the Dark Sky Reserve, "particularly where operations continue into the night" [1]. On air quality, it names the Exmoor Heaths SAC and the Exmoor and Quantock Oakwoods SAC, says both are already under pressure from nitrogen, and calls the predicted improvement "heavily reliant on the emission inventory assumptions", with no sensitivity testing of the assumed ranging emissions [1]. It concludes that the assessment "should be treated with caution" [1]. So the body responsible for the National Park shares the central doubt in this report: the claimed improvement rests on how today's farm was counted.
› Brayford Academy (11 Nov 2026): objection
The Head of School raises air quality, asthma, lorries near school drop-off, drainage and biosecurity, and asks that the combined effects are “fully assessed, with particular regard to the school’s location” [1].
› Communities Against Factory Farming (16 Nov 2026): Independent review
It finds the existing farm’s ammonia overstated “by a factor of approximately 3.6”, and models increases of 31–107% at the three protected points examined. It finds the odour model’s adjustment at high ventilation “has not been adequately justified”, and recommends a revised ammonia assessment before NDC decides [1].
› Devon CPRE (Oct 2026): objection
It objects on landscape grounds, finding the Environmental Statement's landscape chapter lacks a baseline, receptors, viewpoints and a stated method, and asks for further site sections and a quantified cut-and-fill and earthworks strategy, citing the resource and carbon effects of excavating, stockpiling and re-handling about 66,000 tonnes of soil [1]. So an independent countryside body reaches the same view as residents: the landscape effects have been asserted, not assessed.
› Lead Local Flood Authority (4 Nov 2026): objection
Devon County Council’s flood team objects “at this stage”: the drainage scheme does not satisfactorily conform to Local Plan policy ST03, and the applicant must show that “all aspects of the proposed surface water drainage management system have been considered” [1]. It asks for the site’s gradient (infiltration should not be used on slopes steeper than 1 in 10), exceedance routes across the whole site, the roof-water reuse tank on a drawing, and calculations rerun with current rainfall data [1]. So the one consultee responsible for flood risk and drainage has objected, on points this report also raises.
› Letters of support: 2 of 124
North Devon Council’s file holds 124 letters of representation: 121 object, 2 support and 1 comments without taking a side [1]. Neither letter of support is independent of the applicant. One is from 2Agriculture, the poultry processor that buys the farm’s birds. The other is from a local household who describe themselves as friends and customers of the family [1]. Support comes from the farm’s buyer and from friends of the family, and neither engages with the evidence in this report.
2Agriculture’s points:
Old sheds need replacing. That justifies replacing them, not 4.4 times the birds. No smaller option was assessed [1].
Higher welfare at 30 kg/m². The birds would lose outdoor access, and holding 30 kg/m² means catching about 54,000 birds early every crop, which is not assessed [1][17].
Demand is rising. National demand is the buyer’s business case, not a reason to build on this site.
National policy E4 supports it. E4 is weighed against harm, and harm to ancient woodland needs “wholly exceptional reasons” [7].
The assessments show no harm. On the government’s factors ammonia rises about 3.5 times, the odour benchmark used was withdrawn, the flood authority objects to the drainage scheme [1][3][10].
Only a small impact on homes. The applicant’s own model puts Braycross Cottages at 5.57 odour units today and still in the adverse range afterwards, and lorry trips nearly treble past the school [1][11].
Jobs. The gain is 2 full-time jobs, against an Exmoor visitor economy supporting 2,377 [1][27].
Imports are lower standard. A national trade point with no bearing on this application.
The household’s points:
A friendly family selling local beef and lamb. The applicant’s character is not a planning matter, and the beef and lamb business is unaffected.
It keeps the farm in the family. No financial case or smaller option has been submitted [1].
Never noticed any smell. The applicant’s own model shows odour above the old pass mark at nearby homes today, and the Parish Council says homes are “already impacted by the distinct and unpleasant odour” [1].
Can’t see it from the road. The Exmoor National Park Authority confirms the sheds are visible from higher ground within the Park [1].
Newcomers don’t understand farming. Presumptive, inaccurate and demeaning. Objectors include local farmers and lifelong residents, and it has no bearing on this application.
16 · What we ask North Devon Council to do
1. Refuse the application, because the applicant has not shown that it would avoid:
further harm to ancient woodland already above its safe limits, and to Exmoor's protected sites, assessed alone and in combination [7][9];
unacceptable odour, night-time noise, dust and traffic for neighbours, visitors, Brayford Academy and the village [7][26];
risk to groundwater and to a drinking-water catchment;
harm to the setting of Exmoor National Park and its dark skies [7][26].
The Environmental Statement also fails to assess the manure, water, cumulative and night-time effects that the law requires [19][21][22][29].
2. *If not refused now, require further information under regulation 25 of the EIA Regulations, before any decision [29]:
ammonia re-modelled with the government's factors, naming Barton Woods and including acid deposition and in-combination effects;
odour re-modelled with realistic clean-out, night-time fan speeds and site weather, reporting the worst hours, and including every home within 400 m, Brayford Academy and the village hall;
a noise assessment of night catching, thinning, lorries and peak noise;
the breed, slaughter weight and thinning regime;
litter tonnage, a named destination with evidence of a contract, and an assessment of its effects;
the flood risk and drainage report, infiltration tests at the basin and soakaway, groundwater monitoring, and water demand and source;
a transport assessment of the route through Brayford, including construction traffic, a review of the last five years' collisions and a safety assessment of the A399 junction;
an LVIA including views from Exmoor National Park, a heritage assessment and a lighting plan, with further site sections and a quantified cut-and-fill and earthworks strategy;
a non-technical summary and a cumulative assessment.
3. Decide the application at Planning Committee, in public, given its scale and the strength of local concern.
4. Give full weight to the Lead Local Flood Authority’s objection to the drainage scheme, and to the Exmoor National Park Authority’s concerns about air quality, visibility and dark skies [1].
5. Only as a last resort, impose binding conditions that do not accept the harm but limit it:
a maximum of 176,000 birds, with the breed, density and crops a year that were assessed;
no feed, gas, bedding, manure or dirty-water lorries between 19:00 and 07:00, on Sundays and bank holidays, or at school arrival and departure times, with live-bird collection the only exception;
clean-out only on weekday daytimes, and no litter stored in field heaps;
a named litter destination, with tonnages reported to NDC each year;
independent odour checks with a field olfactometer at the nearest homes during catching, clean-out and still evenings, by someone not employed by the operator, with results shared with Brayford Parish Council and work paused above an agreed level;
a standby generator kept on site, shown to be able to run every fan in all four houses, with its position on the plans and its noise assessed;
groundwater monitoring, a lighting scheme for the Dark Sky Reserve, and a construction traffic plan with a highway condition survey before and after.
17 · *What no revision can change
The applicant can answer much of this report with further documents. It cannot answer all of it. If every missing assessment were supplied and every error corrected, the facts of place and scale below would remain, and each is a reason to refuse in its own right.
What new/amended/resubmitted documents could address. A drainage scheme the flood authority accepts. A transport assessment. A landscape and visual impact assessment. An in-combination assessment for Exmoor’s protected sites. A named destination and tonnage for the manure. Corrected odour, ammonia and noise modelling that covers night catching, clean-out, the school and the village hall. A bioaerosol assessment. A cumulative assessment with Brayford Quarry. An accurate public description. Each of these is a gap in the paperwork, and paperwork can be redone.
What it cannot change:
The place. The sheds would sit on a hillside above a village in a valley, with homes to the north-west, north, north-east and south-west [1]. The nearest homes, Braycross Cottages, are about 150 m away, the village hall and pre-school about 335 m and Brayford Academy about 370 m [1][2]. Three of the applicant’s own receptor points sit within 2 m of a valley floor where cold air collects [30]. The Parish Council already raises odour from today’s smaller farm [1]. No model can change which way the land falls, the direction air moves, how it is trapped in the valley, or where the homes and the school are.
The weather. The applicant’s own weather station recorded wind of 1 metre a second or less in 135 of 144 night readings (94%) [1], and historical weather data for the site gives 139–354 still, clear night hours a year in 2022–25 [14]. On those nights cold air drains from the sheds downhill towards Braycross, Brayford and the wooded valley [30]. Where mist gathers in the valleys is where cold air pools on still nights. Our ground analysis shows cold air from the sheds drains into those same valleys [30], so on those nights smell and ammonia released near the ground, during clean-out for example, can be expected to collect there too.The benchmark the applicant presented turns on the worst 2% of hours, about 175 a year: roughly as many hours as these still, clear nights, whose cold-air drainage the odour report does not mention [1]. In other hours, the applicant’s own wind rose shows the wind blows most often from the west [1], towards homes, the Barns at Withygate wedding venue and the ancient woodland to the east [1][30]. The applicant’s own model predicts odour would rise at Withygate [1]. No application can change the weather. When the prevailing wind blows, it carries odour and ammonia towards homes, a wedding venue and woods already over their limits. When it drops, as it does on still nights, whatever leaves the sheds drains downhill towards homes.
The road. There is one road from the A399 to the farm. It leaves a junction with 3 injury collisions since December 2022 [46], runs past Brayford Academy and the village hall [1], through a pinch point residents measure at 3.5 m with no pavement, and past front doors that open beside the carriageway. The only other way in climbs Beara Hill and runs for about 1.7 miles inside Exmoor National Park. A transport assessment can describe this road. It cannot widen it, move the school, change the suitability of the alternative route or create a third way in.
The woodland. The ancient woodland at Barton Woods, within 250 m, is already over both its safe limits before the farm adds anything. Ammonia in the air is 24% over its limit, and the nitrogen settling on the woods is nearly 3 times its limit [1][2]. Additional equipment can reduce but not eliminate what the farm adds. It cannot bring the woods back under their limits, so anything the farm adds pushes them further over.
Exmoor. The National Park Authority confirms the site is immediately outside the Park, and that today’s smaller sheds can already be seen from within it [1]. The boundary follows Holewater Hill, about 200 m north of the sheds, and the Park is also the Exmoor Dark Sky Reserve, which the Local Plan names as “particularly sensitive to light pollution” [26]. A landscape assessment can measure the view. It cannot move the sheds out of the Park’s setting, or remove their effects on the Park and the people who use it.
The scale. 176,000 birds, 4.4 times today. Sheds with 2.8 times the floor area, extending 85–90 m into an undeveloped field. About 1.2–1.3 million birds a year, and lorry visits rising from about 163 to 459–488 a year [1]. More documents cannot reduce the scale. Only a smaller scheme could, and that would no longer be this proposal: it would have to be judged afresh.
The nights. Birds are caught and collected at night [1][2], in a valley where the applicant measured very low background night noise, at just 25 dB [1]. With 4.4 times the birds there would be more catching and more night lorries. Conditions can limit the hours, they can not limit the noise created.
Even a perfect application would still put 176,000 birds on a hillside above a village, served by one unsuitable narrow road past a school, beside ancient woodland already over its limits, on the edge of Exmoor. Those are the core reasons to refuse this application, and no revision can remove them.
Sources
North Devon Council, planning application 82141: the Environmental Statement (Aug 2026), Design and Access Statement, Odour, Ammonia and Dust Reports, Noise Impact Assessment, Transport Statement, Waste Audit, drawings 200_01–200_18, Technical Statement (Trace Design, Nov 2026), consultee responses and public comments. Earlier decisions on the farm (35127, 41689, 41690, 46946, 46951) are on the same portal.
Environment Agency, permit consultation EPR/FP3722MA/A001: application form, Odour and Noise Management Plans, noise and odour risk assessments, Site Condition Report, Dust and Bioaerosol Management Plan, Site Closure Plan, and the EA's request for information (12 Aug 2026).
GOV.UK, Ammonia emission factors for pig and poultry (Dec 2024).
GOV.UK, Intensive farming risk assessment for your environmental permit (May 2026).
Defra, Emissions of air pollutants in the UK: ammonia (Feb 2026).
National Planning Policy Framework (Aug 2026), policies S5, N4, N6, P3 and TR6.
Gailey Lea Farm appeal, APP/C3430/W/25/3366632 (dismissed 24 Oct 2025), paras 11–18.
Natural England, Air pollution and development: advice for local authorities (Dec 2025).
Environment Agency, Odour management: comply with your environmental permit (Dec 2025), section 5.
Institute of Air Quality Management, Guidance on the assessment of odour for planning, version 1.1 (July 2018), Table 7 ("moderately offensive" odours). An updated draft went out for consultation in March 2026.
Footbridge Farm appeal, APP/L3245/W/21/3289216 (dismissed 5 May 2023), paras 8–13.
Norman v Secretary of State for Housing, Communities and Local Government [2018] EWHC 2910 (Admin), paras 10 and 15.
Open-Meteo historical weather (ERA5 reanalysis): night hours with wind of 2 metres a second or less and cloud cover of 40% or less, 2022–25, at the applicant's weather point. Indicative.
Matrix Acoustics, Wrawby Farm, Brigg, noise impact assessment M2531/R01 (22 Oct 2025). Copy available on request.
Welfare of Farmed Animals (England) Regulations 2007, Schedule 5A, and Schedule 1 (back-up ventilation and alarm).
Institute of Environmental Management and Assessment, Guidelines for the Environmental Assessment of Traffic and Movement (2023), Rule 1, as quoted in a published Environmental Statement.
R (Caffyn) v Shropshire Council [2025] EWHC 1497 (Admin), paras 8, 32 and 67–68.
Old Rush Farm Environmental Statement (Harrison Pick for Ruston Eggs, Sept 2025), para 10.2 and Table 3.1.
R (Squire) v Shropshire Council [2019] EWCA Civ 888, paras 39–80.
R (Finch) v Surrey County Council [2024] UKSC 20, paras 77 and 108.
Environment Agency, Catchment Data Explorer: Bray (Source to Hole Water).
Aviagen, Ross broiler handbook: water-to-feed ratio of 1.6–1.8 to 1.
North Devon and Torridge Local Plan 2011–2031 (2018), policies DM01, DM02, DM08 and DM08A; paragraph 5.30.
Town and Country Planning (Environmental Impact Assessment) Regulations 2017, Schedule 4; regulations 18, 25 and 26.
Environment Agency, LiDAR Composite Digital Terrain Model (2 m), analysed by local residents for routes of steepest descent from the sheds. Indicative.
Douglas and others, A systematic review of the public health risks of bioaerosols from intensive farming ( International Journal of Hygiene and Environmental Health 221 (2018).).
Devon County Council planning register, application DCC/4462/2026 (Brayford Quarry, night working of the asphalt plant).
Bureau of Investigative Journalism, Fields of filth (29 Apr 2024).
Shropshire Star, Dozens of complaints over chicken farm smell (23 Apr 2021).
Bureau of Investigative Journalism, megafarms and their neighbours (21 Jul 2017), and Inside a UK megafarm (18 Jul 2017), which spell the farm "Penhros"
Food Manufacture, Chicken slaughterhouse fined £300,000 for failing to stop odour pollution (3 Oct 2022).
Coventry v Lawrence [2014] UKSC 13, Supreme Court press summary.
National Emission Ceilings Regulations 2018: ammonia reduction of 16% on 2005 levels from 2030.
Natural England, Designated Sites View: condition of features, South Exmoor SSSI.
MCBA, Brayford storm overflow, from Environment Agency event duration monitoring annual returns (EA ID SBB00148), 2024–2025: 205 spills and 4,512 hours in 2024; 172 spills and 3,763 hours in 2025.
Devon County Council, SuDS guidance: groundwater monitoring for infiltration schemes (1 m clearance above the maximum groundwater level; ideally a year of readings, or November to May if time is short).
Department for Transport, Road safety open data: police-reported injury collisions 2021–2025, filtered by local residents to the Brayford/A399 junction.
Guadalupe-Fernandez V. et al., Industrial odour pollution and human health: a systematic review and meta-analysis, Environmental Health 20:108 (2021): pooled odds ratios for headache 1.15 and cough 1.27 among exposed residents.
Aviagen, Water Quality (AA Update): water intake "will increase by 6-7% for each degree above 21°C".
Luyckx K. et al., On-farm comparisons of different cleaning protocols in broiler houses, Poultry Science 94 (2015): about 16–18 litres per m² for pressure-washing plus about 1 litre per m² for soaking, applied here to the 10,108 m² of proposed sheds.
Google Earth historical aerial imagery of Higher Hall Farm, dated 2001 and 2010.
Regulation (EU) No 540/2014 on the sound level of motor vehicles (as retained in UK law), Annex III: limit values for category N3 goods vehicles.