15. Other Farms
Updated: Oct 14
People living near large broiler farms elsewhere in England describe the same few problems again and again: smell strong enough to keep them indoors, washing and barbecues abandoned, lost holiday bookings, and years of complaints before anything changed. These accounts do not prove the same would happen at Higher Hall Farm. Farms differ in size, design, management and setting. They do show what living near this kind of operation can be like, and why residents object or ask for binding controls.
The farms described here range from about 190,000 to 235,000 birds at a time, close to the 176,000 proposed at Higher Hall Farm.
In their own words
Newbridge Farm, East Huntspill, Somerset
“The smells from the farm often get funnelled in our direction. They are so bad that it gets into the back of your throat.” [1]
The smell was “so unbearable that you couldn’t sit outside in the smell.” [1]
Residents reported being unable to hang washing out or hold barbecues in summer [1].
The owner of a holiday cabin 200 metres from the farm lost bookings because she “can’t guarantee that the smell won’t be there” [1].
The Environment Agency confirmed complaints were substantiated, and the operator tried changes to feed and a reduction in bird numbers. Public Health England raised concern about homes within 250 metres for bioaerosols and 400 metres for odour [1].
Months later the farm cut its numbers by 120,000 birds, but odour problems continued [2].
Poplars Poultry Farm, Fulmodeston, Norfolk
Villagers described the smell as “unbearable” over three years, and more than 350 complaints about noise and odour were made to the Environment Agency [3].
The Environment Agency required much stronger odour, noise and dust management plans. The operator said it would surrender its permit, and the farm closed in 2020 [3].
The farm later reopened, and villagers then complained of swarms of flies [4].
Hollins Lane, Shropshire (235,000 birds; homes about 460 metres away)
A resident reported more than 80 complaints about “intermittent putrid poultry odour”, while the Environment Agency said the farm was complying with its permit [5]. See Article 14.
Herefordshire
CPRE Herefordshire, reporting on the concentration of poultry units there, says local residents within range “cannot use their gardens or open their windows; they can find it difficult to sell their houses and are not entitled to compensation” [6].
Recurring themes
Theme | What residents report | Relevance to Brayford |
Smell indoors and out | Unable to sit outside, open windows or dry washing | Apart from the applicant’s own farmhouse, the nearest homes are at Braycross, about 150 m away, and Exmoor View is about 8 m from the site boundary [7]. Both are closer than Hollins Lane (460 m) and within the distances Public Health England flagged at East Huntspill |
Timing | Worst in summer and when wind funnels it | West-facing gable fans, a secondary easterly wind, and a site on a col above deep valleys (see Article 4) |
Holiday and rural business | Lost bookings | Exmoor View, about 8 m from the site boundary, is advertised as a holiday let |
Complaints and response | Years of complaints; slow or limited action; sometimes “compliant” | No odour limit at homes is proposed. The only complaint procedure is the operator’s own (see Article 14) |
Outcomes | Changes in feed or bird numbers, stronger plans, or closure, usually after long campaigns | Planning is the stage when limits can be set in advance |
Night-Time Catching Noise
Official Noise Management Assessments submitted to the Environment Agency for large poultry installations explicitly state that bird catching frequently occurs during night-time hours (between 23:00 and 07:00). The noise stems from teams of catching crews, industrial forklifts transferring crates, and internal shouting or mechanical clatter. Noise levels during loading equipment operations regularly spike above 90 dB. [1, 2, 3]
Lorry Disruption & Traffic
The physical infrastructure of Devon’s rural road network often collides with these logistics. For example, in Taunton, an HGV carrying live chickens overturned at 03:30 AM, causing total road closure and major transport infrastructure delays. Standard planning permissions in Devon are said to heavily scrutinize transport routes. Due to these issues, Environmental Permits are routinely forced to mandate restrictions, such as limiting general feed deliveries to daylight hours to mitigate the severe disruptions caused by HGVs navigating unclassified single-track lanes. [1, 2, 3, 4, 5]
See For Yourself A google search for "show me chicken farm smell complaints" examples the effect on residents and communities.
Sources
[1] Burnham-on-Sea.com, “Residents speak out over ‘unbearable smells’ at East Huntspill chicken farm”, 27 March 2018.
[2] Burnham-on-Sea.com, “Chicken farm downsizes by 120,000 birds but odour problems continue”, July 2018.
[3] North Norfolk News, “Chicken farm to shut after complaints of ‘unbearable smell’”, 2020.
[4] North Norfolk News, “Call to close Banham Poultry farm in Fulmodeston over flies”.
[5] Shropshire Star, “Dozens of complaints over chicken farm smell”, 23 April 2021.
[6] CPRE Herefordshire, Intensive poultry units (cpreherefordshire.org.uk).
[7] Author’s measurements using Google Earth; Environment Agency request for more information, 12 August 2026.