2. What the Applicant Claims
Updated: Oct 13
The applicant’s case is that the new sheds would be an improvement on today’s farm, or at worst cause no significant harm, despite holding more than four times as many birds. This section sets out that case as the applicant’s documents present it. The rest of the report tests it.
The applicant's main conclusions
Topic | What the application claims | Where it is tested |
Ammonia† | Ammonia at nearby wildlife sites would fall at all but two of the 19 assessed points, a “considerable betterment” (ES 12.3.7); the report’s own emission figures imply total site ammonia falls about 2.2%. Author correction: today’s farm is overstated; corrected, ammonia rises about 3.5 times | Articles 3 and 9 |
Odour | No assessed home would exceed the odour benchmark under the new scheme. The nearest neighbouring property, Exmoor View, was not assessed | Article 4 |
Dust | No annual air-quality limit would be broken at any assessed home | Articles 3 and 10 |
Noise | No adverse effect at the nearest homes, so "no mitigation is necessary" (Environmental Statement para 9.4.1) | Articles 11 and 12 |
Traffic | No harm to the safety of the road network, so "no further mitigation is therefore considered necessary" (para 15.4.1) | Article 8 |
Health | Disease transmission to residents is rated "Negligible" | Article 10 |
Habitats | A net gain in biodiversity of about 15% | Article 9 |
How the thresholds work, in plain terms
Most of these conclusions compare a predicted figure against a threshold. Readers need to know two things about those thresholds.
First, a threshold is a line drawn for regulation. It is not the point where effects begin. For example, the odour benchmark used is 3.0 odour units† at the 98th percentile†. That means odour at or above that strength is predicted for no more than 2% of the hours in a year, about 175 hours. A home below the benchmark can still notice the smell, sometimes often. Section 4 explains this in full.
Second, some of the thresholds no longer have official standing. The odour benchmark comes from Environment Agency guidance (H4†) that was withdrawn in December 2025. Its replacement, “Odour management: comply with your environmental permit” (3 December 2025), sets no numerical benchmark at all. The applicant’s odour consultant says it is not aware of any replacement, and that the withdrawal has left England and Wales “with no guidance on what level of odour might be problematic”. The dust report chooses which homes to assess using guidance it also describes as withdrawn.
How the "improvement" is calculated
The 2.2% fall in ammonia does not come from cleaner technology. It comes from a calculation error. The ammonia report charges every existing free-range bird place 0.024 kg of ammonia a year for time indoors plus 0.084 kg for time outdoors, 0.108 kg in total, as if each bird spent all of its time both inside and on the range (Ammonia Report, Table 3). The Environment Agency’s published guidance assumes free-range broilers spend about 90% of their time indoors and 10% on the range, giving a combined figure of 0.03 kg per bird place a year (0.0216 kg indoors plus 0.0084 kg outdoors). The report therefore counts ten times too much ammonia from the range and overstates today’s farm about 3.6 times. Corrected, ammonia from the site rises about 3.5 times, from about 1,200 kg to about 4,220 kg a year. Article 3 gives the figures.
The pre-application advice
North Devon Council gave pre-application advice on 12 December 2025 (reference ENQ/0703/2025, officer Chloe Roissetter). The applicant cites it, for example, as confirming the site access is suitable.
The advice letter itself has not been published. The applicant summarises it in the Design and Access Statement (section 4). On the applicant’s own account, the council accepted the principle but made its support conditional: “Officer support would be dependent on the proposal’s compliance with the material planning considerations above including design, amenity, ecology, flooding, drainage and highways” (DAS 4.13). It recommended noise, odour and dust assessments “with a view to ensuring that the operation of the development does not give rise to unacceptable impacts”, and indicated that a Construction Environmental Management Plan was likely to be required as a pre-commencement condition (DAS 4.8). Environmental Health asked that noise, odour and dust be “carefully considered and mitigated where required for nearby receptors” (DAS 4.4).
Two points stand out against what was then submitted:
Neighbours. The receptor lists that followed leave out the nearest neighbouring property, Exmoor View. The Environment Agency found it about 8 m from the installation boundary and asked the applicant to confirm its use and, if it is not associated with the farm, add it to the odour and noise plans (Section 4). Brayford Academy is not named in any of the assessments. By the applicant’s measurements it lies just outside the 400 m list, and the nearest modelled odour and dust point is an unnamed “Brayford” receptor close to the school.
Landscape. The main claim is in the Design and Access Statement, paragraph 4.7. It quotes the council’s pre-application advice as saying that “views of the proposed unit are limited because the topography of the land is relatively low-lying and is well screened from the local highways by established tree lines and hedges”, so it is “unlikely to result in a significant visual impact”. That is the council’s wording as reported by the applicant; the advice letter itself has not been seen. “Low-lying” sits oddly with the applicant’s own descriptions of the site: at 200 to 210 m “on a col amongst moorland edge slopes with deeply incised river valleys” (odour report), with sheds at 210 to 220 m (EA Site Condition Report). In autumn and winter, and when the lane hedges have been cut, the sheds are visible from Holewater Hill and Whitefield Lane. The Environmental Statement contains no landscape and visual impact assessment: its two-page landscape chapter relies on the planting plan, yet still predicts a “moderate adverse residual visual effect” (ES 13.1.2). Visual impact is not covered by the permit either; the Environmental Statement notes that visual impacts “are not considered in the permitting process” (ES Chapter 2).
Supporting lines in the permit papers:
Site Condition Report, Environment Agency permit papers (July 2026): "Soil bunding and tree planting will help to minimise the visual intrusion normally associated with poultry units."
Dust and bioaerosol management plan (14 August 2026): "Poultry house screened by extensive hedges/buildings."
The advice was given on 12 December 2025, nine days after the H4 odour guidance was withdrawn. The full letter can be requested from North Devon Council under the Environmental Information Regulations.
What is promised, and in what form
Almost all the mitigation the applicant offers is in narrative form. It appears as statements of intent, good practice, or management plans to be prepared or followed later. No draft permit conditions have been submitted. Whether any of these promises could be enforced is the subject of Section 14.
What the council's advisers have said so far
These consultation responses are listed on the North Devon Council planning portal for application 82141. At the time of writing their documents could not be opened online, so their content is not summarised here. Copies can be requested from the council; check the portal for later responses.
South West Water – 18 September 2026
Environment Agency – 18 September 2026
North Devon Council, Environmental Health – 18 September 2026
North Devon Council, Sustainability – 23 September 2026
Devon County Council, Waste Management – 24 September 2026
Devon County Council, Historic Environment Team – 28 September 2026
Brayford Parish Council – 29 September 2026
Natural England – 1 October 2026
Devon County Council, Highways and Lead Local Flood Authority – none listed at the time of writing
Many planning applications are decided by a planning officer under delegated powers rather than by the planning committee. Residents who want this one decided in public can ask their district councillor to request that it is referred to committee.