top of page

4. Smell

Oct 5
4 min read

Updated: Oct 13

The applicant predicts that no home would exceed the odour benchmark. That is a prediction about a yearly statistic. It is not a prediction that residents will not smell the farm, and the applicant’s own permit papers rate the likelihood of neighbours being exposed to odour during clean-outs as “Likely”. This is the only article in this residents' report that analyses odour in full. Other articles refer back here.


What the model predicts

Receptor (applicant's naming)

Distance (applicant's figure)

Today

Proposed

Farmhouse (applicant's own)

about 118 m from the site boundary

7.51

2.04

Braycross Cottages

about 190 m from the sheds

5.57

2.15

Catkins

about 270 m from the sheds

2.96

1.21

The Bungalow

—

1.23

1.25

Beara Hill

—

0.36

0.54

Withygate

—

0.34

0.37

Figures are odour units† per cubic metre at the 98th percentile†, from the applicant's Odour Report (Table 2). The benchmark used is 3.0.


Two points stand out. Today’s farm is already modelled at 5.57 at Braycross Cottages, 86% above the benchmark, although the Environmental Statement says only that it “exceeds” the benchmark. And at The Bungalow, Beara Hill and Withygate the predicted odour goes up, not down.


What the prediction does not tell you

It is a yearly statistic, not a description of any one day. A 98th percentile figure ignores the worst 2% of hours in a year, about 175 hours. Strong odour during those hours does not count against the benchmark. Below the benchmark, a home can still notice the smell on many more occasions.


Odour is not steady through a cycle. It is lowest when chicks arrive and highest in the last week or two, when the birds are heaviest. It peaks again when the sheds are cleaned out. In 2023 a planning inspector dismissed an appeal for a broiler farm at Footbridge Farm, Tasley, near Bridgnorth in Shropshire, partly because the odour assessment “fails to consider peak odour concentrations at the end of the growing cycle and during the clearing out of the poultry buildings” (appeal APP/L3245/W/21/3289216). Article 14 has more on this case.


Clean-outs would be more frequent. Each shed is emptied and cleaned at the end of every cycle. With shorter cycles, clean-outs across the four sheds rise from about 22 a year to about 28 to 30 a year. These are among the strongest odour events on a poultry farm.


Wind direction decides who is affected. The prevailing wind is from the west and south-west, which carries emissions away from Brayford. The wind rose also shows a secondary peak from the east. On those days, emissions from the west-facing gable fans of Sheds 1 and 2 would travel towards the nearest homes. The applicant does not assess these conditions separately.


Still, damp evenings are the hardest case to model. The site is on a col above deep valleys. The odour consultant changed a standard setting the model uses for hilly ground. The consultant’s own explanation is that the default setting can over-predict ground-level concentrations from raised sources, such as the new roof fans, in still weather and light winds, and grossly under-predict them from low-level sources, such as today’s sheds. The change “approximates the normal behaviour of ADMS with flat terrain”. On that explanation, it lowers the predictions for the proposed sheds and raises them for today’s farm in exactly the conditions residents find hardest. Article 12 explains why this matters.


Which homes are counted

The applicant’s odour and noise plans list 17 sensitive receptors within 400 metres, of which 12 are described as homes, one of them the applicant’s own farmhouse. The village hall is on the list, at 397 metres. The author’s own approximate count, measured from the farm boundary, is 16 homes within 400 metres: 6 in High Bray and 10 on the Brayford side, including Exmoor View. Also within 400 metres on the author’s measurements, but not on the applicant’s list, are Brayford Academy, the playground and the site of 14 proposed new homes. The author’s Google Earth map, with measurements that differ from the application’s, can be found here.


On 12 August 2026 the Environment Agency asked the applicant to confirm the use of Exmoor View, a converted barn about 8 metres from the site boundary, and, if it is not associated with the farm, to add it to the receptor tables in the odour and noise plans. The only odour plan supplied is dated July 2026 and does not include it. The applicant’s dust plan calls the building a staff dwelling. It is advertised as a holiday let on Higher Hall Farms' website and AirBnB.


What protects residents if the prediction is wrong

Very little that is binding:

  • No odour limit at any home has been proposed as a permit condition.

  • H4 has been withdrawn, and the Environment Agency’s replacement guidance sets no numerical benchmark to measure a limit against.

  • The main operational promise is to avoid clean-outs when the wind blows towards homes “if at all possible”. Homes surround the farm on three sides.

  • The applicant’s Environmental Statement suggests that in rural communities “considerable tolerance of odour may develop”.


Article 14 explains how odour complaints are handled once a farm holds a permit, and why compliance with a permit does not always mean the smell stops.




Source:

 
 
bottom of page