top of page

6. Manure: Where Does It Go?

Oct 6
3 min read

Updated: Oct 13

The application gives several different answers about where the litter goes, and none of them is binding. The headline answer is an anaerobic digestion† (AD) plant, which turns manure into energy. But no plant is named, no contract is shown, and the applicant’s own Manure Management Statement calls details of spreading “assumptions only”.



Different answers in the applicant’s documents

The Manure Management Statement says: "Any further details on the location of land used for spreading are assumptions only at this stage. The EIA does not accept conjecture."


Document

Where it says the litter goes

Non-Technical Summary, Odour Assessment, Site Condition Report, Technical Standards, permit application form, Environmental Statement (Chapter 19)

Sold or exported to an anaerobic digestion plant (the Environmental Statement adds “outside of the catchment area”)

Environmental Statement (5.1.19 and 6.1.3)

Removed by a third-party contractor; where it is spread is “assumption only, and conjecture”

Manure Management Statement

Spread by third parties, following the Code of Good Agricultural Practice

Permit application form (8l)

Not spread on land owned or controlled by third parties

Site Closure Plan

Used “on operator controlled land as fertiliser”, or sold

Contingencies document and Technical Standards

“Agreement with neighbouring farms for removal”; neighbouring farms to take it in an emergency

Emergency Plan

A contact line for “Emergency Litter Disposal / Temporary Field Storage”

Waste Assessment and Waste Management Plan

Not listed as a waste stream at all


What is actually shown

Nothing in the application names:

  • an AD plant, or shows it has agreed to take the litter;

  • any fields that would receive spread litter;

  • the soil nutrient levels of those fields, or spreading rates and frequency;

  • how nitrogen limits would be met.


Nitrogen limits

The farm lies in a Nitrate Vulnerable Zone† (NVZ), as does much of the surrounding land. Wherever litter is spread in an NVZ, livestock manure is limited to an average of 170 kg of nitrogen per hectare per year across the receiving holding, with a field limit of 250 kg per hectare from all organic manures in any 12 months. Records must be kept of where manure goes and how much is spread.


The official figures for broiler manure (Nitrate Pollution Prevention Regulations 2015) put the nitrogen produced by a meat chicken at 1.06 g a day. Using the applicant’s own bird numbers, growing days and flocks per year, the litter would contain about 49 to 55 tonnes of nitrogen a year (author calculation). At 170 kg per hectare, spreading it would need roughly 290 to 320 hectares of land each year. None of this can be checked, because no receiving land is named.


Possible AD destinations in the area include Condate Biogas, near South Molton, which uses crops and poultry waste from local farms, and Nomansland Biogas, near Tiverton, which lists poultry litter among its feedstocks. The applicant has not named either plant or supplied a contract with any plant. The Transport Statement counts manure lorries per cycle but does not assess where they would go, the routes they would take or the distances involved.


If the arrangement changes

An AD contract is a commercial agreement. It can end, the plant can close, or the price can change. If the litter can no longer go to AD, the fall-back routes in the applicant's own documents are local spreading or removal by neighbouring farms. That would mean:

  • Storage. Litter may need to be stored on site or on receiving farms, with its own odour, ammonia and run-off.

  • Transport. The vehicles, routes and distances would change. Tractors and trailers on local lanes would replace, or be added to, lorries to a plant.

  • Spreading. Odour and dust from spreading would affect homes near the receiving fields, which may be close to Brayford. Nutrients could run into the River Bray and on to the River Taw.


Once litter leaves the farm, the operator's main duty is to record the dates and amounts. Where it is spread is controlled by the farming rules for the receiving land, not by this farm's permit.


What the courts have said

This is not a technicality. In R (Squire) v Shropshire Council [2019] EWCA Civ 888, the Court of Appeal quashed planning permission for a poultry unit rearing about 1.6 million broilers a year. The Environmental Impact Assessment had not properly assessed the odour, and the dust, from storing and spreading the manure, including about 1,150 tonnes a year on unidentified third-party land. The court held that the assessment was “incomplete and unlawful”. Article 14 returns to this case.

Sources:

 
 
bottom of page