top of page

8. Traffic

Oct 6
9 min read

Updated: Oct 13

On the applicant’s own figures, lorry visits to Higher Hall Farm rise from about 162 a year to between about 460 and 490 a year. That is roughly 920 to 980 lorry movements through the lanes, about three times today’s level (ES paras 15.3.5, 15.3.7, 5.1.2). The application describes this as “approximately 1 trip per day” (ES 15.3.7), but the traffic is not spread evenly. It comes in bursts around bird collection and clean-out, and the operator’s own Environment Agency papers say bird catching “frequently” happens at night.


There is only one road from the A399 to Holewater Hill and the farm, it runs through the village and past the school. Every lorry, during construction and once the farm is operating, would use it (CEMP 3.2). The application assesses only the farm entrance. It does not assess that road or its suitability for the vehicles stated, the peak days, the night-time movements or where the manure lorries go.



Today (free range)

Proposed (housed)

Source

Bird places

nearly 40,000

176,000

ES 3.1.2, 1.1.1

Crop cycle

66 days

49 days

ES 15.3.4, 15.3.6

Crops per year

about 5.5

7 to 7.5

ES 15.3.4, 5.1.2; odour and ammonia reports

Lorry visits per crop

29.5

65.5

ES 15.3.5, 15.3.7

Lorry visits per year

about 162

about 460 to 490

calculated from the rows above

Lorry movements per year (in and out)

about 325

about 920 to 980

calculated

The yearly figures are worked out from the ES's per-crop numbers and crops per year. The ES itself does not give an annual total.



The crop cycle and when the lorries come

Nearly half of each crop’s 65.5 lorry visits arrive in the few days of bird collection and clean-out, not at “1 trip per day”. The proposal runs 7 to 7.5 crops a year on a 49-day cycle. Chicks arrive on day 1, finished birds leave at about day 39, and clean-out takes 7–10 days (ES 5.1.2, 6.1.4).


Feed lorries rise from 7 to 26 per crop and bird lorries from 6 to 22. Manure loads are shown falling from 11 to 8 even though bird numbers rise 4.4 times (see Weaknesses, row 5). Illustrating peaks in each crop:


  • Chicks in: 4 lorries of day-old chicks per crop (up from 1), plus 1 bedding lorry (ES 15.3.6).

  • Feed: 26 lorries per crop (up from 7), each carrying up to 28 tonnes (ES 5.1.12, 15.3.6). That is about 180 to 195 feed lorries a year. The application does not say how deliveries are spaced through the crop.

  • Birds out ("depopulation"): 22 lorries per crop (up from 6) (ES 15.3.6). The application does not say over how many days or nights this happens. The operator's own Environment Agency (EA) noise assessment says bird catching is "frequently occurring during night time".

  • Clean-out: 8 manure lorries and 1 dirty-water tanker (ES 15.3.6). The operator's EA Odour Management Plan says litter goes out "within 24 hours following destocking per house (48 hours total for site)".


Taken together, bird collection and clean-out bring 31 of the 65.5 visits (62 of 131 movements) into a window of a few days. If catching took two nights, that would be roughly 11 bird lorries a night. This is an illustration only, because the application gives no timetable.



Feed and bird-collection drive the rise in lorry visits per crop

Free-range production creates 29.5 lorry visits per crop, the new intensive production would result in 65.5 lorry visits per crop. Every visit requires a "to and from", so traffic is twice the below number of lorry vists. Note, not all traffic is included in this graph.


Above: lorry visits per crop (cycle). Dead bird collection is once every 2 cycles. Data source: application Environmental Statement, paragraphs 15.3.4 and 15.3.6.



Aside from the traffic quoted the application leaves out figures for:


  • Staff and workers: listed as a traffic source (ES 15.3.3) but never counted. The unit would employ 4 full-time and 1 part-time staff (ES 20.3.3).

  • Contractors: catching crews, pressure-washing contractors (ES 5.1.17), vets and pest control are not counted.

  • Thinning: the planning documents do not mention thinning, where some birds are taken out early. The operator’s EA Odour Management Plan does refer to work “following bird thinning”. At the ES’s stated 30 kg/m², the sheds could hold about 113,500 birds at finishing weight, so about 62,500 birds (around 35%) would need to leave early in every crop. That means extra catching nights and extra bird lorries that are not in the traffic figures.

  • Dead-bird collections: the ES counts one collection every two cycles. The operator’s EA documents describe collection “twice weekly” under the National Fallen Stock Scheme, which would be about 11 collections while each crop is on site. With expected mortality of 3%, about 5,300 birds would die in each crop. The vehicle type is not stated, so these collections are not counted anywhere in the traffic figures.


There's also no mention of the vehicle traffic from other farm operations that relate to the production of cattle, sheep or egg production.




The route through Brayford and highway safety

The application judges highway safety on the farm entrance alone. The road between the A399 and the farm, through Brayford and past its primary school, is not assessed.


What the documents say about the route

  • Construction route: construction vehicles come from the A361 onto the A399, then "through the village of Brayford" to the existing site entrance (CEMP 3.2). The CEMP expects "an increase in traffic through the village of Brayford" (CEMP 5.1).

  • Location: the farm is about 0.5 miles east of Brayford, reached off Holewater Hill and then a private drive (ES 3.1.1, 15.2.1). The drive is about 180 m long (CEMP 2.1).

  • School: the CEMP notes "there is a school in the village of Brayford". It only asks contractors to avoid peak times "wherever possible", and only during construction (CEMP 3.4).

  • Operational route: after construction, the route for feed, bird and manure lorries is not stated anywhere in the application.

  • Other buildings on the road: the operator's EA Noise Management Plan lists 17 sensitive buildings within 400 m. They include homes off Holewater Hill and Barton Lane and the village hall off Holewater Hill.


The author’s Google Earth map shows Brayford Academy beside the village road at the eastern end of Brayford. That is the stretch every lorry would use between the A399 and Holewater Hill. The author has also measured two pinch points on this road: about 3.5 m (11.5 ft) at the Old Post Office and about 4.6 m (15 ft) at The Old Baptist. These are the author’s observations, not something the application states.



What the application's safety assessment covers

Topic

What the application provides

Source

Site entrance visibility

"good visibility in either direction", attributed to the council at pre-application

ES 15.2.2; DAS 4.11

Accident record

No Crashmap records in 10 years "along Holewater Hill or surrounding the site access"

ES 15.2.4

Highways authority input

Devon Highways gave only "standing advice" at pre-application

DAS 4.4

Road widths, passing places, A399 junction

Nothing

—

Lorry sizes and turning paths

Only that feed lorries carry 28 tonnes

ES 5.1.12

Pedestrians, school times, cyclists, horse riders

Nothing

—

Mitigation

"No further mitigation is therefore considered necessary"

ES 15.4.1


Policy cited in the application

  • National policy: the ES says the new NPPF policy TR3 makes the "principal considerations" the effect of traffic on the local network, highway safety, and the environmental impacts of associated traffic (ES 4.1.8).

  • Local Plan: the ES lists policies DM05 (Highways) and DM01 (Amenity) as relevant (ES 4.2.5).

  • The ES's conclusion: the impact is "not severe" and there are "no grounds for refusal on highway grounds" (ES 15.5.1).



Weakness and contradiction in the transport evidence

The two-page Transport Statement and ES Chapter 15 contradict other parts of the application on traffic. They also leave out the information an objector most needs.


#

Issue

What the documents say

Why it matters

1

Averaging

"approximately 1 trip per day in the cycle" (ES 15.3.7)

It obscures the collection and clean-out peak of about 31 visits in a few days.

2

Noise report says traffic won't change

"no change to the frequency or nature of transport movements", so transport noise is left out (Noise Impact Assessment s.2; ES 9.3.4)

ES 15.3.7 shows lorry visits per crop more than doubling. The noise conclusion rests on a false premise.

3

"Minor" increases

"any minor increases in traffic movements" (DAS 5.3.7) The applicant’s own figures show 2.2 times more visits per crop and about 2.8 to 3 times more per year.

The applicant's own figures show 2.2 times more visits per crop and about 2.8 times more per year.

4

Different manure distribution stories

“assumptions only… The EIA does not accept conjecture” (ES 5.1.19, 6.1.3); spreading by third parties under the farming code (Manure Management Statement); “all litter removed off site for energy generation” (ES 19.1.1); taken “outside of the catchment area” to anaerobic digestion (ES 19.1.4 only); sold to an anaerobic digestion plant (EA permit form, Site Condition Report and Non-Technical Summary)

No plant, route or distance is named, so the manure lorry journeys are not assessed at all.

5

Fewer manure loads for 4.4 times the birds

11 tractor-trailer loads per crop today for nearly 40,000 birds; 8 lorries per crop proposed for 176,000 (ES 15.3.4, 15.3.6)

No litter tonnage is given anywhere, so the figure of 8 cannot be checked against the application. Using the government’s official manure figures, 176,000 birds would produce about 390 to 410 tonnes of litter per crop. Spread over 8 loads, that is about 50 tonnes of litter per lorry, more than the 44-tonne legal limit for a fully loaded lorry (see Article 5). EIA rules quoted in the ES itself require an estimate of residues “by type and quantity” (ES 1.3.1(d)).

6

Gas lorries

Increase of "2 per cycle" (ES 15.3.8) versus "2 per year" (Transport Statement)

The two transport documents disagree with each other.

7

Staff and contractors

"Staff & Workers" listed as a traffic source (ES 15.3.3)

They are never counted, nor are catching crews or washers.

8

Bird numbers

176,000 places (ES 15.3.2) versus 173,926 (ES 3.1.4); annual output 1,232,000 (ES 15.3.2) versus 1,223,355 (ES 5.1.8)

It shows the chapters were not checked against each other. The bird-number differences are small (1–2%). The bigger gap is crops per year: 7 in the ES against 7.5 in the odour and ammonia reports, a difference of about 7% in every yearly total.

9

Construction traffic

Works last about 46 weeks (ES 21.1.3) but vehicle movements are described as lasting "only a short period" (ES 21.2.1). No construction vehicle numbers are given.

Demolishing 4 sheds and handling 66,800 tonnes of inert material on site (Waste Audit Statement) is a long programme, with all access through Brayford (CEMP 3.2).

10

Night-time limits are optional

Delivery hours of 07:00–20:00 "can be implemented" (EA noise assessment), or apply "if required" (EA Noise Management Plan)

Nothing binding limits night-time lorries.

11

Nobody else controls traffic

The EA permit does not consider traffic directly (ES 2.2, item 7)

Only the council can impose limits on lorry hours and routes, through planning conditions.

12

Called a "Transport Assessment"

"an appropriate and proportional Transport Assessment" (ES 15.1.1)

It has no route survey, no counts, no peak analysis and no swept-path drawings.


Night-time traffic and bird catching

The operator's own permit papers confirm regular night-time catching, with lorries, forklifts and reversing alarms. The planning application does not assess any of it.


  • Night catching is routine: The scale: 22 bird lorries per crop, 7 to 7.5 times a year, so about 154 to 165 bird lorries a year, up from about 33 today (ES 15.3.4, 15.3.6; annual figures calculated).

  • Alarms and vehicles at night: "Audible reversing warnings mostly during daylight hours, excepting during night catching". Small vehicles are "driven slowly on site for night catching" (same document).

  • Equipment involved: forklifts move crates between the sheds and the lorries, and "Lorries scheduled to minimise duration of catch" (EA Noise Management Plan).

  • The scale: 22 bird lorries per crop, 7 times a year, so about 154 bird lorries a year, up from about 33 today (ES 15.3.4, 15.3.6; annual figures calculated).

  • Not assessed: the planning noise report leaves transport out entirely (Noise Impact Assessment s.2). It also never applies the sleep guideline it quotes, that sudden noises indoors should not exceed 45 dB LAmax more than 10 times a night (NIA s.3.2).

  • Lorries at night on the village roads: the application does not say whether bird lorries pass through Brayford at night. For construction traffic the stated route is through the village (CEMP 3.2).

  • Manure removal hours: the ES recommends avoiding manure clearing "in the evening unless it is absolutely necessary" (ES 8.4.2). The EA plans put litter removal at 07:00–18:00. Neither is a binding planning condition.





Sources

Paragraph references used relate to these documents:

Planning application (North Devon Council)

  • ES: Environmental Statement, Acorus, August 2026: Chapters 1–5, 6, 8, 9, 15, 19, 20 and 21.

  • TS: Transport Statement (undated, 2 pages).

  • DAS: Design and Access Statement, Acorus, August 2026.

  • CEMP: App 8, Construction Environmental Management Plan, Connops, 9 July 2026, revision 0.1.

  • NIA: App 3, Noise Impact Assessment M2613/R01, Matrix Acoustics, 8 June 2026.

  • Manure Management Statement.

  • Waste Audit Statement.

  • App 2 and App 6: Odour and Ammonia reports.

  • Environment Agency permit application EPR/FP3722MA/A001 (24 July 2026)

  • Noise and Vibration assessment.

  • Noise Management Plan.

  • Odour Management Plan.

  • Site Condition Report.

  • Non-Technical Summary.

 
 
bottom of page