16. Combined Effects
Updated: Oct 13
The applicant assesses each effect separately, against its own threshold, and finds each one acceptable. What the application never shows is the combined burden on one small area: the same homes, lane, woodland and groundwater receiving several effects at once, on top of existing farming and an industrial quarry. Assessing effects one by one is how the system works, but it cannot answer the question residents are actually asking.
The same places, several effects at once
Who or what | Effects from the farm | Already there | Assessed together? |
Nearest homes (from about 150 m; Exmoor View about 8 m from the site boundary) [1] | Odour, dust, fan and night noise, lorries, light | Quarry dust, farm traffic, new homes | No |
The road, village, school and village hall | About 3 times the lorries, night catching, construction, possibly AD haulage | School run; a 14-home scheme near the farm at consultation stage (author’s information), which substantially increases the homes on this road and adds about 28 cars near the school (assuming two per home); other businesses at Higher Hall Farm; traffic from other farms; pinch points and few passing places | No |
Ancient woodland | Ammonia at up to 76.8% of the Critical Level from the farm alone [2] | Background already above the Critical Level [2] | No. The report gives the background level but does not add it to the farm’s contribution |
Exmoor designated sites | Small ammonia and nitrogen additions [2] | Nitrogen deposition already about three times the Critical Load [3] | No. The report treats an in-combination assessment as unnecessary, partly because emissions would fall [2], which relies on the overstated figure for today’s farm (see Article 3) |
Groundwater, springs and the River Bray | Roof and yard run-off, dirty water, spills, possible manure spreading | Farming nitrate in a Nitrate Vulnerable Zone [4] | No sampling and no monitoring [4] |
Landscape and Exmoor’s setting | Large buildings, silos, lighting, lorries, earthworks | Next to Exmoor National Park [5], an International Dark Sky Reserve | No landscape and visual impact assessment, no viewpoints [6] |
Why separate assessments understate the burden
Each threshold looks at one pollutant. Annoyance from smell, sleep lost to night noise, and stress from lorries on the road add up for the same household. No threshold covers that combined experience.
Other sources are left out. The quarry, its proposed night working, other farms and a proposed 14-home scheme on the same road do not appear in the applicant’s assessments. If both the farm and the housing go ahead, the same road and the same stretch past the school would carry both, and nobody appears to have considered them together.
The baseline is already stretched. The ancient woodland and the Exmoor sites are already above their limits before the farm adds anything [2][3]. Background PM2.5 is more than half of the 10 µg/m³ standard the applicant’s own dust report uses [7]. A small addition to an exceeded limit is still an addition. As the inspector at Footbridge Farm put it, an existing exceedance “is not justification to make an undesirable situation even worse” [8] (see Article 14).
The uncertainties stack up. Bird numbers, crops per year, litter quantity, litter destination, water use and the modelling settings are each uncertain (see Articles 1, 5, 6, 7 and 12). Several assessments depend on the same uncertain inputs, so an error in one input affects several results at once.
The heading is misleading. The ES section on ammonia is headed “Assessment/Cumulative Effect” [9], but it only sets out the screening thresholds and compares today’s farm with the proposed one. It does not assess this farm together with other sources.
The scale behind it
All of these effects grow with bird numbers. The application would take the farm from about 40,000 birds to 176,000. The applicant claims improvements in ammonia, odour and visual impact (see Article 2). Its own ammonia figures imply a fall of about 2% in total emissions [2], but only because the figure for today’s farm is overstated. On the Environment Agency’s own emission factors, ammonia from the site would rise about 3.5 times [10] (see Article 3). The question for the council is whether an increase of about 340% in capacity at this site is acceptable once everything is considered together.
Sources
[1] Author’s measurements using Google Earth; Environment Agency request for more information, 12 August 2026.
[2] Ammonia report (App 6), AS Modelling & Data, 13 May 2026: section 3.4, Table 3 and results tables.
[3] SCAIL screening: cover note, inputs and results (planning file, 9 September 2026).
[4] Site Condition Report, Environment Agency permit application, 24 July 2026.
[5] Exmoor Historic Environment Record, MEM25359: National Park boundary cairn at Bray Cross.
[6] Environmental Statement, Acorus, August 2026: Chapter 13.
[7] Dust report (App 4), AS Modelling & Data, 18 May 2026: background concentrations and results for annual mean PM2.5.
[8] Appeal decision APP/L3245/W/21/3289216, Footbridge Farm, Tasley, Bridgnorth, 5 May 2023, paragraph 32.
[9] Environmental Statement, Acorus, August 2026: section 12.3.
[10] Environment Agency, Ammonia emission factors for pig and poultry (gov.uk).