3. Ammonia and Dust
Updated: Oct 25
The sheds would release ammonia and dust into air that already carries ammonia from farming and dust from Brayford Quarry. The applicant assesses the farm’s own emissions but not those of the quarry. This article covers air pollution only. Odour is covered in Article 4, and the combined effect of all the issues in Article 16.
Ammonia
The applicant’s ammonia report gives the site’s annual ammonia as about 4,320 kg today and 4,224 kg under the proposal - barely a change. This minor difference is an error explained in Article 2: the report counts today’s free-range birds as if each spent all of its time both indoors and on the range. Using the Environment Agency’s published factor for free-range broilers, today’s farm releases about 1,200 kg a year. The proposal would release about 4,220 kg, roughly 3.5 times as much.
What matters for the countryside is where the ammonia lands. The applicant’s own figures show the nearest ancient woodland well past its Critical Level† today, and still close to it under the proposal. The “today” figures use the same overstated range emission, so the real present-day figures are lower than shown and the improvement is smaller:
Ancient woodland point | Today (% of Critical Level) | Proposed (% of Critical Level) |
Receptor 1 (nearest) | 303.5% | 76.8% |
Receptor 2 | 169.8% | 80.5% |
Receptor 3 | 116.8% | 38.2% |
These are the farm’s contribution only. Background ammonia in the area is already about 1.24 µg/m³ (micrograms per cubic metre of air), above the 1.0 µg/m³ Critical Level for mosses and lichens before the farm adds anything. Background plus the proposed farm at Receptor 1 comes to about 2.0 µg/m³, roughly double the Critical Level. Article 9 covers what this means for the woodland.
The applicant’s own tables also show increases. Ammonia would fall at all but two of the 19 assessed wildlife points. The two increases are at North Exmoor SSSI† (from 0.21% to 0.31% of the Critical Level) and at South Exmoor SSSI†, which is also part of the Exmoor Heaths Special Area of Conservation (from 0.19% to 0.30%). These are small, but they are increases. The applicant’s earlier screening (SCAIL) put the farm’s contribution at North Exmoor SSSI at 3.6% of the Critical Level, about ten times the detailed model’s figure. With today’s farm corrected, more of the assessed points would be likely to show an increase.
Dust and fine particles
The Environment Agency’s standard emission factor for broiler dust is 0.1 kg per bird place per year. On that factor, 176,000 birds would release about 17.6 tonnes of dust a year, compared with about 4 tonnes from today’s 40,000. These are the author’s calculations from the standard figure, not ones the applicant states.
Poultry-house dust is not ordinary dust. It comes mainly from bedding, feed, droppings and feathers inside the sheds, and can carry micro-organisms and their products, known as bioaerosols. The Health and Safety Executive research cited in the applicant’s dust report measured farm workers’ exposure to “airborne dust and bioaerosols (micro-organisms and their products)”. The dust report assumes about a third of the dust by weight is PM10† and about 7% is finer PM2.5†.
The applicant's dust report finds:
• No annual air-quality limit would be broken at any of the 17 homes and other buildings assessed. Exmoor View, the nearest neighbouring property, was not among them.
• The 24-hour PM10 limit “may be exceeded very close to the poultry houses, specifically near the gable end fans”. The gable fans of Sheds 1 and 2 face west, towards Brayford; those of Sheds 3 and 4 face east.
• At the worst-affected assessed point, the farm alone would add 32.7% of the 24-hour PM10 assessment level.
• Its own short-term figures “should only be used comparatively”, because emissions vary and the model assumes a steady output.
The dust report gives no figures for today’s farm, so the change cannot be measured. It also assumes birds are grown to about 38 days, with about 7.5 flocks a year; the Environmental Statement assumes about 7.
The existing background: Brayford Quarry
Brayford Quarry, run by Heidelberg Materials UK (formerly Hanson), quarries and crushes sandstone. Health and Safety Executive guidance lists sandstone as more than 70% crystalline silica. The quarry runs an asphalt plant, and in May 2026 its operator applied to Devon County Council to run that plant overnight, from 6pm to 5am, on up to 50 nights a year until the end of 2029. The outcome of that application has not been confirmed.
The quarry is not mentioned anywhere in the applicant’s documents. The background dust figure used comes from a national modelling grid, not local measurement. That grid shows PM10 of about 11.3 µg/m³ in the square nearest the quarry, against about 9 to 10 µg/m³ in surrounding squares. Background PM2.5 at the site is about 5.7 µg/m³, more than half of England’s legally binding target of 10 µg/m³, which must be met by 2040.
Why pollution sources have to be added together
Each source is regulated on its own: the farm by its permit, the quarry by its own permit, traffic by nothing in particular. Residents breathe the total. On the evidence available, the proposal would add a permanent new source to an area that already has an unassessed industrial dust source and woodland already over its ammonia limit.
Sources: